Question about SF camp

[loramin]

Originally Posted by soronil [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Seriously dude? you just added bold to part of the sentence and ignore the next 6 words which completely changes the meaning completely.

I was highlighting the important part. Look, you can argue with me all you want, but I don't make the rules. All I do is copy what the GMs say to the wiki, and then rearrange the relevant parts into a single place (the Camp Rules page).

As for everything else you wrote ... I:

Originally Posted by soronil [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

just don't see any evidence/basis for your argument.

You didn't provide a single quote, let alone one where a GM says "this is how you take a camp without killing a mob". And that doesn't surprise me: I took the time to compile staff rules quotes awhile back (see http://wiki.project1999.com/Rulings), and none of them mention anything about taking camps for mobs you haven't killed.

Also, to be clear, like many of my wiki projects I started the Camp Rules page because I saw certain forum threads being repeated, and I thought a wiki page would be a better solution to share the information. I did not do it because I have any personal stake in interpreting any specific ruling in any particular way. Everyone is welcome to interpret what I assemble however they wish.

Ultimately, neither you nor I will know for sure if you're correct unless A) a GM shows up in this thread, or B) you get into a camp fight and petition. Until one of those two things happens, all anyone can do is speculate.