Qeynos Interrogator's Badge Quest (#2)

[poena.dare]

I hit Theodore Exanthem once. He started hitting me back.

I waited a bit but he showed no sign of capitulating, so I hit him again. That was probably a big mistake. Not wanting to kill him I /quit. When I logged back in the interrogator was still at the hermit hut but no sign of Theodore Exanthem.

Anty way to reboot this step or am I going to have to start all over again with the Qeynos Investigator's Badge Quest (#1)?