Help with Mantle of souls quest!

[William_Munny15]

Was wondering if anyone has gotten the mantle of souls lately that can tell me if I did something wrong. http://wiki.project1999.org/Azraxs%27_Legacy

I did all the steps correct up until the end apparently, I got the completed soul trap after combining the three quest pieces, I went to turn in the completed soul trap to the tormented soul, with amiably faction by the way, and he ate the item, and said "you must prove yourself to the heretics before i reward you with such an item" The quest calls for kindly faction... and I was amiably, just would like to know if it's something I did wrong?