Raid Scene: Tools & Rules Suggestion

[Swish]

Originally Posted by -Catherin- [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I dont really understand why Sirken supported FTEing a mob in a certain zone and then leaving it up to contest somewhere else and be able to kill at your leisure.

But he did. Going for another mob should forfeit any other currently active FTE but /shrug.

You're lucky you weren't banned for using autofire in Sol B, I wouldn't needle the staff too much lol

[-Catherin-]

Originally Posted by Swish [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

You're lucky you weren't banned for using autofire in Sol B, I wouldn't needle the staff too much lol

You have no idea what you are talking about as usual. Go back into retirement and stay there this time.

[eadric]

Originally Posted by -Catherin- [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I dont really understand why Sirken supported FTEing a mob in a certain zone and then leaving it up to contest somewhere else and be able to kill at your leisure.

But he did. Going for another mob should forfeit any other currently active FTE but /shrug.

I think he most likely made a ruling based on limited and/or flawed information, in a game that he doesn't currently play or have extensive knowledge of. Listening to portions of the raid summit podcast, I noticed that he didn't know what zone Yelinak is in. That's not to bash him at all... just to give some perspective. When a judge has limited knowledge and possibly bad or falsified evidence, it's more understandable to see a completely baffling and incredulous ruling like this. The alternative explanation is much less palatable, given Sirken's repeated use of the mantra "follow the spirit of the rules" above all else.

Seems like people are a little too worked up over it, though. I mean, these kinds of shenanigans are the standard on this server and have been for years. Aftermath implicitly warned the rest of the server in the raid discussion thread that if they didn't clarify the time limit to engage after the foot race FTE, it would be exploited. It was argued over and no resolution was reached, so they exploited it. Nothing surprising at all here, except for the fact that Sirken backed them up. And he could always reexamine that ruling with a more complete set of facts, and change his mind.

[Kodim]

Except racing only applies to Kael and VP, and there's a good chance the upcoming rule changes will fix those issues.

[Imposter]

a guild "FTE'd" Tormax and Statue in Kael.

said guild left the zone to contest mobs in TOV.

you would think FTE was dropped at that point, right?

Why would Sirken hover over Kael and protect that guild's right to FTE on those mobs for an hour?

I smell a marshmellow conspiracy.

[Bozena]

Originally Posted by Kayso [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Then you're obviously the one to come up with some creative and innovate solution that 100s of other people haven't thought of. Problem solved. Good work.

Sarcasm. How constructive.