Found my first a-hole on the Blue Server

[loramin]

So that's a different scenario: in dungeon zones you can claim multiple mobs in very close proximity as a camp. In this case, it sounds like the group did have the claim to the camp, because they had killed a (different) mob previously.

However, I (greatly) sympathize with your point that it's impossible to know what counts as a camp sometime, and the staff does change their opinions from case to case. I also sympathize with the staff: having to consult a rules bible every time they interact with players would make their (volunteer) lives much harder.

My "solution" has been to put a lot of time and effort into https://wiki.project1999.com/Camp_Rulings. It doesn't yet have a ruling for Vilefang, but if you can post whatever the GM told you (and when) I can add it, and it will at least help educate future players.

[druidbob]

Originally Posted by loramin [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

So that's a different scenario: in dungeon zones you can claim multiple mobs in very close proximity as a camp. In this case, it sounds like the group did have the claim to the camp, because they had killed a (different) mob previously.

However, I (greatly) sympathize with your point that it's impossible to know what counts as a camp sometime, and the staff does change their opinions from case to case. I also sympathize with the staff: having to consult a rules bible every time they interact with players would make their (volunteer) lives much harder.

My "solution" has been to put a lot of time and effort into https://wiki.project1999.com/Camp_Rulings. It doesn't yet have a ruling for Vilefang, but if you can post whatever the GM told you (and when) I can add it, and it will at least help educate future players.

aa

But then wouldn't that be the same case here? The Warrens is a dungeon, assuming OP was killing kobolds in the surrounding area would he not have the same claim to the king as that group had to VF?

[loramin]

Originally Posted by druidbob [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

aa

But then wouldn't that be the same case here? The Warrens is a dungeon, assuming OP was killing kobolds in the surrounding area would he not have the same claim to the king as that group had to VF?

OP would have to be killing mobs from that "camp". If they were, then yes, but just killing any nearby kobolds wouldn't qualify (and AFAIK there's been no official GM ruling of what the "king" camp is, so I would imagine it's only mobs immediately next to him, as they have to be in agro range).