@CSR

[Pootle]

How are you going to stop or police having a whole bunch of people turn up to the roll and all rand for their one guildmate who is doing the quest?

Jomar's point is actually good.

c) only one turn-in per character

otherwise the proposed agreement is effectively creating a low-barrier cash cow where each roll's turnout will be 2-5x as large as the current turnouts and there is real disincentive for sharing the timer.

You will get a lot more people doing the quest multiple times for MQ sales, as it will simply be a few mins to hammer and run over for the roll. So you will now be rolling against many more people.