Quote:
Originally Posted by Woke Locc
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
Off Topic be like that.
Question - was the f35 intended for dogfighting?
|
It has a terrible wing loading and an okay thrust-to-weight ratio. It implies an a/c which will have a fairly wide turn radius and that'll bleed energy rapidly in any sort of hard maneuver. It does not have enough of a T/W advantage over its likely opposition to be able to reliably over-power them the way an F-4 could dance on the heads of MiG 17's back in the 60's. The vision out of the cockpit is not great. Nearly any purpose-built fighter will exceed its performance in those areas. A close-in knife-fight will play away from its strengths to put it mildly.
It's at its best destroying enemy from a distance when the other guys don't even know it's there and for penetrating enemy air defense. It has an excellent radar and very good missles and datalink provides excellent situation awareness of the larger battlefield. It should be effective as an interceptor provided it can be waiting for its targets in advance; it isn't fast enough to run stuff down. It should also be very good as a tactical bomber which I suspect will prove to be its primary use.
The Navy version has a much greater wing area and may wind up somewhat better in a close-in fight, although this is mostly a side-effect of the Navy wanting lower landing speeds and more fuel capacity. I prefer to think of the F-35A as a modern take on the F-105, mainly a bomber with secondary air-to-air capability. The excessive cost will hurt it as its users will have a hard time fielding enough of them and also likely prove hesitant to place it in harm's way.
This ignores its great many teething troubles and delays, which taken together could fill several volumes. It's a troubled program. In the end I expect it'll prove to be a functional aircraft and decent at several specific jobs, but one that'll never live up to its lofty original goals even after all the cost overruns....shades of the F-111 program. History repeats except this time we don't have McNamara to blame.
Danth