there is a private list system going on at AC in OOT?

[cd288]

Originally Posted by loramin [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

The explicit/specific/"a GM once said it" rule is that the person with the camp (ie. the top of the list) must be honest about who they are giving the camp to next:



There is no such explicit ruling for anyone else on the list, and in fact there are no explicit rules about lists at all except for that (that I know of) ... aside from the global "don't be a dick".

But that last one is important. There is for instance this explicit chunk of the Play Nice Policies:



So when I say things are unclear, it's not because this place has no rules, but just that no GM has explicitly addressed a particular case. If someone pulls list shenanigans, would the staff consider that fraud? Maybe, maybe not, we have to wait until it happens to see.

I’ve had multiple guides and GMs over the years enforce an order if someone told you that your turn was next for the camp and then tried to slot someone else in ahead of you. Come to think of it, Ive actually never had an instance where a staff member did not enforce that if the person ahead of me told me I was next or refused to tell me who was in front of me.

General rule of thumb is that if you’re a dick like that the staff is not going to look kindly upon you and will rule against you.