Monk or Ranger for soloing melee?

[Wallicker]

Ranger at 50: Monk at 50:
Def. 200. Def. 230
Dodge. 137. Dodge 200
Parry 185. Block. 200
Riposte 150. Riposte. 200
Offense. 210. Offense. 230
Dual Wld 210. Dual Wld. 252
Dbl atk. 200. Dbl atk 210
1HS. 200. H2H. 225


Spells + bowkiting. Mend + FD + combat BW + Flying kick
BiS weapons yaks. BiS weapons fists
8/24 ratio is .333. 14/30 ratio is .466

In classic it’s quite obvious the monk is a stronger soloer, sure a ranger can bow kite something to death outdoors but this can take a realllly long time if it’s not a blue which the monk could kill easier. I’d say outdoors tie indoors monk wins by a bit. This is all assuming OP is asking about leveling a monk or ranger on teal/green right now in similar gear. Really two yaks for the ranger is pushing it right now. Not to mention hybrid penalty for ranger.