Raiding Guild Behavior

[Maner]

Originally Posted by Pokesan [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

isn't it a little hypocritical for you, Maner, to accuse anyone of arguing in bad faith?

No, I literally mean that the incident in question was worked out at the time it happened and both sides supposedly left in good faith. except someone in CSG decided to petition anyway after the fact, apparently without the guild leaders approval. Which to be honest I didn't even know was allowed when petitioning other guilds.

This just brings up an even bigger grey area though. The rules state to work things out with other guilds first. This was worked out to the satisfaction of both parties at the time and then petitioned later.

The crying wolf thing is just as stupid as nothing was ever actually conceded it was 2 guilds working out what happened that ended with another suspension. So now the big question is why bother trying to work it out? Safer to just let people break the rules and petition after since whoever is handing out 10days now either is being lied to or is completely biased in their rulings.