the server, loot and the way things are

[Taluvill]

What I think a lot of you Pro-Rotation people seem to think is that a lot of people want to share their pie with everyone.

I would imagine, if there was a rotation with IB/Div/DA, there would be some good favor to it. This solution also puts every guild under them at a reduced class and makes them feeder guilds for the "Big 3" and ruins the fun for anyone not in those guilds/potential new guilds.

If you force the big three to share with say, 8 guilds, which I can EASILY see happening with a widespread rotation, why would any of these 3 agree to it? they can all get raid mobs when they feel like it and get more than 1 every two weeks. They could have 3-5 every week, potentially. They won't agree to it, and it's as others have said, big guilds will be cockblocking, for lack of a better term, old type content to gear up newer members, pad their guild bank, and bring new recruits up to gear(ish) the moment they join and earn their favor.

A rotation, as much as you want it, will not work on the sole fact that there are too many people who have done this, and too many people that would jump at the chance to monopolize the server and raid frequently.