Actually Realistic Proposal for the Server

[Nefarum]

It's not necessarily a 3-guild rotation. It still encourages competition, but makes the competition more viable for lesser-than-TMO guilds. A guild like BDA/Divinity/etc. will have more of a chance getting a mob if 2/3 of the top guilds have to sit out that pop. Lesser guilds will only have 1 of the top 3 to contend with (along with the other lesser guilds).

I honestly think just a small change like this, plus the addition of Velious content is all we really need. Keep in mind I'm not even a member of a top 5 guild and I'm saying this.

This just prevents such a ridiculous bottleneck on key items, like Trak teeth.

---> One more thought:

I honestly don't believe there will ever be a proposal that will have unanimous agreement. The GMs' mandate for us to reach a consensus is pretty much impossible. We could have a near-perfect plan, and there will still be people who don't like it. No matter what, the top guilds have to give up power, and/or the lower guilds will still feel oppressed. I think no matter what happens, the GMs might have to just choose a proposal that isn't universally reviled and just declare it the new law. That's the only way I see anything actually moving forward.