Server Raid Rules - New and Improved

[Skope]

But, Nilbog, doesn't

If 45+ players simultaneously charged Nagafen, I think it would be pretty fun myself, no need for GMs.

essentially one of the problems that we recently had all over again? There were player-made rules that were promised to be enforced by a particular GM that filled out the gaps in the rules that we had before, these rules were disobeyed and that same GM claimed (and you did, as well) that only the official rules would be enforced. This "grey area" that guilds have to decide for themselves (whether at the target/zone or via forums/vent?) wouldn't be considered one of the official rules? Because guild C can promise guild B for a shot after guild A wipes, but then just hop in and take it and it's all fine and dandy.

I guess my questions are: is it FFA/FTE when things get ugly? Because that's the current vibe im getting. or are we to being asked to fill in the gaps again with no GM backing? is there going to be some sort of slap on the wrist for guilds who disobey the player-agreed-upon rules, if any are made?

45+ people engaging a target just means one guild right now, and in the past week there's been 2-3 instances where zones were pushing over 120 people, so a little clarification on whether it's FFA as soon as it pops if a guild isn't in aggro radius, or whether there will be fill-ins for these instances by GMs or player-made would be greatly appreciated.

EDIT: depopping it is fine, but that won't need to keep occurring if some of the holes are patched up.