Need legal advice from red99 PnP lawyers, Monk FD scenario, is it "legal" or not

[Tradesonred]

You run up to a monk, hes fighting a single mob. You engage him, he feigns death to clear aggro, it aggros you, the monk engages you.

To me this should be legal, FD is part of the arsenal of the monk.

I dont like PnP, i think even training should go unpunished, but im not going to try to change that, it can get bad enough that i understand the rationale behind not wanting to allow people to train.

But this is a completely different scenario to my mind, and i just want to make sure this is perfectly legal.

[Elderan]

Transferring aggro from one person to another is considered a train.

Another example of a train. A person runs to a group of 2 and aggros 2 mobs while running to them. One of the two people in that group he is attacking heals someone, the aggro transfers to that person/group. That is also a train.

[Tradesonred]

Originally Posted by Elderan [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Transferring aggro from one person to another is considered a train.

Another example of a train. A person runs to a group of 2 and aggros 2 mobs while running to them. One of the two people in that group he is attacking heals someone, the aggro transfers to that person/group. That is also a train.

When the monk is on the offensive, i can understand. The monk getting jumped though, to me he should be allowed to FD to defend himself.

[Elderan]

Originally Posted by Tradesonred [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

When the monk is on the offensive, i can understand. The monk getting jumped though, to me he should be allowed to FD to defend himself.

The person attacking is taking advantage of the player who is currently attacking a mob. The monk in this case should either fight with the mob on them, run away and then FD dropping aggro when the attacker is not in aggro range.

[SamwiseRed]

Originally Posted by Elderan [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

The person attacking is taking advantage of the player who is currently attacking a mob. The monk in this case should either fight with the mob on them, run away and then FD dropping aggro when the attacker is not in aggro range.

you stupid? if im a monk, sk, necro the first thing im gonna do if attacked is clear agro off me. same as if i was a cleric, i would DA. only an idiot would think this is training.

[Elderan]

Originally Posted by SamwiseRed [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

you stupid? if im a monk, sk, necro the first thing im gonna do if attacked is clear agro off me. same as if i was a cleric, i would DA. only an idiot would think this is training.

This is how it has been ruled in the past. Any transferring of aggro from you to another player is considered a train.

[Naeyi]

Originally Posted by Elderan [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

The person attacking is taking advantage of the player who is currently attacking a mob. The monk in this case should either fight with the mob on them, run away and then FD dropping aggro when the attacker is not in aggro range.

So because a monk is soloing when someone tries to pk him, the monk is required to tank two targets OR run away and magically drop aggro while being pursued? Someone help me out, this guy is a troll right.

[SamwiseRed]

Originally Posted by Naeyi [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

So because a monk is soloing when someone tries to pk him, the monk is required to tank two targets OR run away and magically drop aggro while being pursued? Someone help me out, this guy is a troll right.

ignore elderan, he is a moran.

[Nirgon]

Originally Posted by Naeyi [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

So because a monk is soloing when someone tries to pk him, the monk is required to tank two targets OR run away and magically drop aggro while being pursued? Someone help me out, this guy is a troll right.

First, he's not a troll. He's the count with assburgers.


Second, if someone attacks you while fighting something, you can FD it off. If it aggros them, its their fault for risking something like that.

[Fame]

Originally Posted by Elderan [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

The person attacking is taking advantage of the player who is currently attacking a mob. The monk in this case should either fight with the mob on them, run away and then FD dropping aggro when the attacker is not in aggro range.

Faggot