Project 1999

Go Back   Project 1999 > Blue Community > Blue Server Chat

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #51  
Old 07-24-2013, 12:48 AM
xCry0x xCry0x is offline
Sarnak


Join Date: Feb 2013
Posts: 399
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sarius [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
I don't think that this is likely, especially since one seller with a brand new forum account was called out and did not bother to defend his sale or continue trying to sell it.
I really love this forum sometimes. I can throw out a completely plausible idea and someone always lets me know how what I throw out there is unlikely because of equally unfounded reason x, y, z.

How is it more likely that people are duping items than it is likely that people are simply re-selling shit? That is the whole appeal to ec trading, you buy an item and try to flip it. Who knows why someone would want to do it anon, hell, maybe they forgot their forum username/pw and just created a new account?

Back to the topic at hand though.. the guy in the other thread said he duped items by mistake which resulted in both item & plat getting duped.

Explain why anyone would continue to dupe items vs just duping plat when duped plat isn't trackable? (one of the admin/gms/devs said this in a tiggles interview iirc)
__________________
-------------
Halmir - 60 Cleric
  #52  
Old 07-24-2013, 12:52 AM
Widan Widan is offline
Fire Giant


Join Date: Nov 2009
Posts: 559
Default

Maybe the person duping items didn't know that plat could be duped using the same method...until that stupid person posted his story instead of contacting staff.

Quote:
Originally Posted by xCry0x [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
How is it more likely that people are duping items than it is likely that people are simply re-selling shit? That is the whole appeal to ec trading, you buy an item and try to flip it. Who knows why someone would want to do it anon, hell, maybe they forgot their forum username/pw and just created a new account?
Also you can just go to http://ahungry.com/eqauctions/ and check trends to see what there has been an influx of. And this is only what has been seen in EC, so you can add some from the forums on there too.

Edit:
Quote:
[1 days ago] Tallahassee auctions, '(WTS) Amulet of Necropotence , Master Wu's Trance Stick.'
[2 days ago] Tallahassee auctions, '(WTS) Amulet of Necropotence , Crimson Robe of Alendine.'
[3 days ago] Spellvendor auctions, 'wtt Amulet of Necropotence seeking 58+bard epic prefer.'
[3 days ago] Spellvendor auctions, 'WTTAmulet of Necropotence for, UBER account ... prefer bard.'
[1 weeks ago] Vazex auctions, '(WTS) Sebilite Scale Cap1k/Silken Whip of Ensnaring750p/Diamond2k/Black Sapphire2.7k/Lamentation5k/Amulet of Necropotence500k/Spell: Banishment of Shadows5k/.'
[1 weeks ago] Vazex auctions, '(WTS) Sebilite Scale Cap1k/Silken Whip of Ensnaring750p/Diamond2k/Black Sapphire2.7k/Lamentation5k/Spell: Banishment of Shadows5k/Amulet of Necropotence 500k/Spell: Splurt450p/.'
[2 weeks ago] Nuvar auctions, '(WTS) Amulet of Necropotence.'
[4 weeks ago] Cinn auctions, 'Runed Fighters Staff , Amulet of Necropotence .'
[5 weeks ago] Solkunar auctions, 'Amulet of Necropotence, Cobalt Bracer, Fingerbone Hoop, Lamentation.'
[5 weeks ago] Ogrimso auctions, '(WTS) Amulet of Necropotence 500K.'
[5 weeks ago] Ogrimso auctions, '(WTS) Amulet of Necropotence.'
[5 weeks ago] Solkunar auctions, 'Amulet of Necropotence, Cobalt Bracer.'
[5 weeks ago] Cinn auctions, 'Amulet of Necropotence, Runed Fighters Staff.'
[6 weeks ago] Cinn auctions, 'Amulet of Necropotence.'
[40 weeks ago] Kiphi auctions, '(WTS) Obulus Death Shroud , Prayer Shawl , Amulet of Necropotence (WTS).'
[43 weeks ago] Fratii auctions, '(WTS) , Rod of Annihilation, Amulet of Necropotence , (WTS) .'
[44 weeks ago] Rikezib auctions, '(WTS) Amulet of Necropotence, Cobalt Breastplate, Shield of Rainbow Hues .'
[44 weeks ago] Rikezib auctions, '(WTS) Amulet of Necropotence, Cobalt Breastplate, Shield of Rainbow Hues .'
[44 weeks ago] Rikezib auctions, '(WTS) Amulet of NecropotenceAmulet of Necropotence
[45 weeks ago] Kengu auctions, '(WTS) , Amulet of Necropotence , Rod of Annihilation Rod of Annihilation
[45 weeks ago] Azerel auctions, '(WTS) Amulet of Necropotence, (WTB) Donals Breastplate
[71 weeks ago] Joyous auctions, '(WTS) Blood Point, Adamantite Club, Amulet of Necropotence,Mask of Obtenebration,Tranquil Staff,Sebilite
[73 weeks ago] Tenda auctions, '(WTS) Amulet of Necropotence , Thex Dagger , Tobrin's Mystical Eyepatch , Manastone , Cloak of Flames , Cobalt
That's 7 different char's selling AoN's in EC over the past 6 weeks, compared with 7 in the previous year and a half. Yes, this website does not have all the data since it's only active when someone is uploading their logs, but it's pretty good at spotting inconsistencies with items.

edit: before anyone points it out, there's a bit of a gap in data from 23 weeks ago - 39 weeks ago I believe, but you can compare the rest
Last edited by Widan; 07-24-2013 at 01:19 AM..
  #53  
Old 07-24-2013, 12:55 AM
Sithel1988 Sithel1988 is offline
Sarnak

Sithel1988's Avatar

Join Date: Sep 2011
Posts: 347
Default

i agree, wipe clean
  #54  
Old 07-24-2013, 01:07 AM
xCry0x xCry0x is offline
Sarnak


Join Date: Feb 2013
Posts: 399
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Widan [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
Maybe the person duping items didn't know that plat could be duped using the same method...until that stupid person posted his story instead of contacting staff.



Also you can just go to http://ahungry.com/eqauctions/ and check trends to see what there has been an influx of.
I think that is a stretch that the person who figured out how to dupe items overlooked trying to dupe plat if in the end plat is all they really wanted =P
__________________
-------------
Halmir - 60 Cleric
  #55  
Old 07-24-2013, 01:11 AM
citizen1080 citizen1080 is offline
Planar Protector

citizen1080's Avatar

Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Your Wallet
Posts: 2,980
Default

1. Find and fix the dupe
2. Server ~3 week rollback
3. 3x Xp for ~3 weeks
4. Profit

Yes, it would suck for those who put in a ton of time lvling during the ddos. But I think the majority of us have not gotten much accomplished during the last few weeks.

In fact it drove many extra people to EC to trade since thats all they could do safely, which made the trading of duped items that much worse.

On the flip side if the dupe is fix and ddos gone having a 2x/3x xp period would put most of us well ahead of where we were as we could focus on lvling during the period for better gains.

The only issue major issue i see right off the bat would be account trades would be an issue. The plat x traded to y for an account rolls back...but the account info does not. So anyone who bought an account during the roll back period got it for free and those who sold are screwed.

But...tracking these few sales down and making it right would be a lot less work for the staff than chasing down duped items traded 3-4 times each through the logs.

Anyways...just an idea other than wipe it clean...wipe it kinda clean!
__________________
Bob the Broker
  #56  
Old 07-24-2013, 01:23 AM
xCry0x xCry0x is offline
Sarnak


Join Date: Feb 2013
Posts: 399
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by citizen1080 [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

In fact it drove many extra people to EC to trade since thats all they could do safely, which made the trading of duped items that much worse.
Which could also explain the influx of high end items being traded around =P

I honestly think people underestimate the novelty-ness of an AoN... I had one on live and I sold it after a couple of weeks because other shit is more worthwhile.

It is awesome until someone is selling a Donal's bp and will take the AoN as trade, ch clicky > skeleton clicky =P. Then all of a sudden the DOnal's bp vendor is selling AoN and you get a cycle of that item showing up over and over again.
__________________
-------------
Halmir - 60 Cleric
  #57  
Old 07-24-2013, 01:31 AM
Widan Widan is offline
Fire Giant


Join Date: Nov 2009
Posts: 559
Default

One more long post of EC logs from that site. Keeping in mind there is that gap of data I mentioned from 23 weeks ago - 39 weeks ago, I think we can see the duping most likely started 5-6 weeks ago, or at least that's when the dupers wanted to start unloading.

Just look at the extreme price drop and influx of thex daggers here (I deleted the WTB''s and price checks from the data)

Quote:
[1 days ago] Sweet auctions, '(WTS) Spell: Sunstrike , Thex Dagger, PST.'
[1 days ago] Bob auctions, '(WTS) Thex Dagger , Oggok Cleaver , Incarnadine Breastplate , Sarnak Warhammer , Rubicite set , Tolapumj's Robe , Book of Obulus , Golden Chitin Bracer , .'
[1 days ago] Sweet auctions, '(WTS) Thex Dagger , Spell: Sunstrike , Spell: Flaming Sword of Xuzl , , PST.'
[2 days ago] Gannacus auctions, '(WTS) Thex Dagger, Spell: Minion of Shadows, Spell: Naltron's Mark, .'
[3 days ago] Waterlilly auctions, '(WTS) Thex Dagger 90k, PST.'
[3 days ago] Sweet auctions, '(WTS) Thex Dagger , Spell: Sunstrike, PST.'
[3 days ago] Gannacus auctions, '(WTS) Thex Dagger, Spell: Minion of Shadows, Spell: Naltron's Mark, Stone of Morid.'
[1 weeks ago] Bob auctions, '(WTS) Thex Dagger , Truncheon of Doom , Oggok Cleaver , Rubicite Set , Incarnadine Breastplate , Sarnak Warhammer , .'
[3 weeks ago] Veloci auctions, '(WTS) { Rod of Annihilation } 310k ,{ Cloak of Flames } 135k, { Thex Dagger } 110k, { Hierophant's Cloak } 45k (WTS).'
[3 weeks ago] Veloci auctions, '(WTS) { Rod of Annihilation },{ Cloak of Flames }, { Thex Dagger }, { Hierophant's Cloak } (WTS).'
[3 weeks ago] Veloci auctions, '(WTS) { Rod of Annihilation },{ Cloak of Flames }, { Thex Dagger }, { Hierophant's Cloak }.'
[3 weeks ago] Supremacy auctions, '(WTS) Rod of Annihilation 310k, Thex Dagger 110k.'
[4 weeks ago] Hueylewis auctions, '(WTS)/WTT Thex Dagger 150k, OBO // full visible set (1 bracer) of Rubicite armor 100k, OBO, , PST!.'
[4 weeks ago] Hueylewis auctions, '(WTS)/WTT Thex Dagger 150k, OBO // full visible set (1 bracer) of Rubicite Breastplate 100k, OBO, , PST!.'
[4 weeks ago] Aalpha auctions, '(WTS) Thex Dagger 200k litmited time offer.'
[5 weeks ago] Brainstorm auctions, '(WTS) << Thex Dagger >> 150k obo.'
[5 weeks ago] Brainstorm auctions, '(WTS) Golden Efreeti Boots 6k // Fishbone Earring 4k // << Thex Dagger 150k >>.'
[42 weeks ago] Vorg auctions, '(WTS) Thex Dagger.'
[42 weeks ago] Vorg auctions, '(WTS) Mithril Breastplate, Thex Dagger.'
[42 weeks ago] Vorg auctions, '(WTS) Mithril Breastplate, Crown of King Tranix, Thex Dagger.'
[43 weeks ago] Tridred auctions, '(WTS) Crown of King Trannix , Thex Dagger..'
[43 weeks ago] Tridred auctions, '(WTS) Crown of King Tranix 15K, Thex Dagger 150K.'
[43 weeks ago] Tridred auctions, '(WTS) Crown of King Tranix 15K Thex Dagger 150K.'
[45 weeks ago] Baxter auctions, '(WTS) blue diamond 3k, black sapphire 2500, sarnak warhammer 5k, tolapumj robe 3k, staff of the undead legions 1k, golden efreeti boots 4500. (WTB) thex dagger, sheild of the immaculate.'
[50 weeks ago] Cees auctions, '(WTS) Thex Dagger 130k , Dragon Hero Bracer 95k , Tobrin's Eyepatch 65k , Green Dragon Shield 45k , Red Dragon Armor 30k , Gaunts of Fiery Might 30k , Totem of Wizened Spirits 30k.'
[51 weeks ago] Migooth auctions, '(WTS) , Thex Dagger 150k, Manastone 110k, Dragon Hero Bracer 100k, Dawn, Fire, Morning Star of Light 40k, Kavruul`s Mystic Pouch 15k.'
[52 weeks ago] Niah auctions, '(WTS) Puppet Strings / Thex Dagger / Co, F /, BCG / No, S / Green Dragon Shield / Red Dragon Armor / White Dragon Cloak / Dawnfire / Gaunts of Fiery Might / Dragon Hero Bracer / Tobrin's Eyepatch / Totem of Wizened Spirits / T-Staff / Iksar Regen, BP / Fingerbone Hoop / Selo's Drums /, FBSS /, IGS /, GEBs / Idol of Thorned.'
[52 weeks ago] Niah auctions, '(WTS) Puppet Strings / Thex Dagger / Co, F /, BCG / No, S / Green Dragon Shield / Red Dragon Armor / White Dragon Cloak / Dawnfire / Gaunts of Fiery Might / Dragon Hero Bracer / Tobrin's Eyepatch / Totem of Wizened Spirits / T-Staff / Iksar Regen, BP / Fingerbone Hoop / Selo's Drums /, FBSS /, IGS /, GEBs / Idol of Thorned.'
[52 weeks ago] Dontaze auctions, '(WTS) , Thex Dagger 150k, Goblin Gazughi Ring 10k, Bracer of the Hidden 6k.'
[52 weeks ago] Dontaze auctions, '(WTS) , Thex Dagger 150k, Necklace of Superiority 35k, Goblin Gazughi Ring 10k, Bracer of the Hidden 6k, Shrunken Goblin Skull Earring 2k.'
[52 weeks ago] Dontaze auctions, '(WTS) , Thex Dagger 150k, Necklace of Superiority 35k, Goblin Gazughi Ring 10k, Djarns Amethyst Ring 10k, Bracer of the Hidden 6k, Shrunken Goblin Skull Earring Shrunken Goblin Skull Earring
[54 weeks ago] Zathrus auctions, '(WTS) Thex Dagger 175k, Fungus Covered Scale Tunic 70k.'
[72 weeks ago] Nizzarr auctions, '(WTS) Thex dagger, pm with offer.'
[73 weeks ago] Tenda auctions, '(WTS) Amulet of Necropotence , Thex Dagger , Tobrin's Mystical Eyepatch , Manastone , Cloak of Flames , Cobalt Helm.'
If you check high end items a lot of them have similar patterns to this. The price drop indicates that most of them are probably unique daggers and not the same one being passed around or auctioned from someones many alts.
  #58  
Old 07-24-2013, 01:33 AM
Sarius Sarius is offline
Fire Giant


Join Date: May 2013
Posts: 604
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by xCry0x [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
I really love this forum sometimes. I can throw out a completely plausible idea and someone always lets me know how what I throw out there is unlikely because of equally unfounded reason x, y, z.

How is it more likely that people are duping items than it is likely that people are simply re-selling shit? That is the whole appeal to ec trading, you buy an item and try to flip it. Who knows why someone would want to do it anon, hell, maybe they forgot their forum username/pw and just created a new account?

Back to the topic at hand though.. the guy in the other thread said he duped items by mistake which resulted in both item & plat getting duped.

Explain why anyone would continue to dupe items vs just duping plat when duped plat isn't trackable? (one of the admin/gms/devs said this in a tiggles interview iirc)
Perhaps they are duping both. In the other thread the PP and the headband were duped. Maybe the hypothetical scumbag is trading 500K for an AoN and duping both in the process.
  #59  
Old 07-24-2013, 01:39 AM
citizen1080 citizen1080 is offline
Planar Protector

citizen1080's Avatar

Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Your Wallet
Posts: 2,980
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Widan [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
One more long post of EC logs from that site. Keeping in mind there is that gap of data I mentioned from 23 weeks ago - 39 weeks ago, I think we can see the duping most likely started 5-6 weeks ago, or at least that's when the dupers wanted to start unloading.

Just look at the extreme price drop and influx of thex daggers here (I deleted the WTB''s and price checks from the data)



If you check high end items a lot of them have similar patterns to this. The price drop indicates that most of them are probably unique daggers and not the same one being passed around or auctioned from someones many alts.
Thex dagger may be a poor item to gauge this by. I have a client who recently came back to game, well before the ddos, who had a stockpile of daggers. He was one of the first 50's on the server and was in a position to farm them.

I sold 4-5 of these for him over a ~3 week span.

So part of the influx on these was from him/me and legit.

However, the ones ive been seeing sold currently are not from anyone I sold to as far as i know.

Also I do agree with Halmir, if the duping is purely for RMT purposes they would just dupe plat and if they did dupe high end items they would just want to keep those stockpiled to sell to people for cash, not put them out on the market were young detectives can start connecting dots.
__________________
Bob the Broker
  #60  
Old 07-24-2013, 01:51 AM
Widan Widan is offline
Fire Giant


Join Date: Nov 2009
Posts: 559
Default

It's possible, though CRoA's also follow this same exact pattern of becoming extremely common 5-6 weeks ago. I haven't looked at any others.

Also red flags go up when a character has a lot of platinum, that's how stabbyjoe got caught, from the platinum, not the 50 500k items he stole or whatever, so maybe they thought it would be safer. I mean it's all just speculation now.
Closed Thread


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 10:21 PM.


Everquest is a registered trademark of Daybreak Game Company LLC.
Project 1999 is not associated or affiliated in any way with Daybreak Game Company LLC.
Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.