What is the absolute WORST zone in the game? VOTE NOW

[Check12345]

Originally Posted by Legday [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

How is West Karana not running away with this?

Yeap!

#TeamWestKarana

[Nirgon]

East commons tunnel and the non classic economy here

[Ella`Ella]

Originally Posted by Nirgon [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

East commons tunnel and the non classic economy here

How does a purist like you dislike EC?

[Muggens]

Tov, hate, skyshrine and sky are sucky zones. Atleast theres a neat froglok village in Swamp of No Hope

[Valakut]

qeynos sewers

[Tuurin]

Most obvious answer is not even listed- Lake Rathetear. Pointless zone in the middle of nowhere that brings nothing to the table other than certain classes that are required to do some penance epic work there.

Of those listed plane of sky is worst for me. Corpse-dragging shenanigans/keys/hitboxes make every visit a pain imo.

[Zuranthium]

My least favorite is Befallen because it's so unimaginative, straight out of some kind of stereotypical D&D undead dungeon box, and the zone is such a pain in the ass to play through as an actual lowbie dungeon, without any great rewards either (aside from one camp that does drop a good low/mid level weapon for tank classes). Never had any good experiences there.

And now a big rebuttle to everyone who's hating on outdoor zones:

Originally Posted by Tuurin [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Most obvious answer is not even listed- Lake Rathetear. Pointless zone in the middle of nowhere that brings nothing to the table other than certain classes that are required to do some penance epic work there.

Lake Rathe is a great leveling spot for the earlier levels and was full of people back in the day. I think the zone design is cool too.

Originally Posted by Gilder [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

How Dagnor's Cauldron only has 8 votes is beyond me. That zone is beyond boring and such a pain to walk into. That was my vote, though I was tempted to go Emerald Jungle just because it's such low visibility, high aggro zone.

It's always been a big disappointment how little there is to do in Dagnor's, but I think it looks unique, so it has that going for it. The zone at least gives Unrest much more mystique, because of the travel required to get there.

I love forest zones like Emerald Jungle and on PvP servers you get some really fun fights there. I do wish actually hunting in the zone was more relevant though, and in my ideal conception of the game world there would be a boat going from Steamfont Mountains to the Northeast corner of EJ.

Originally Posted by Venjenz [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Lesser Fay.

As said in the thread that prompted the poll - does anyone ever do anything in LFay besides hug the zone wall on the way to Mistmoore, kill the Nybright sisters, or run away from brownie scouts and/or the dumbass unicorn?

I would never pick big zones that you can get lost in as a worst, because that in itself is interesting to me. People did camp things here during Original EQ, the orcs and bandits and faeries, and also the NPC's next to the Steamfont zoneline. Hugging the wall to MM is very inefficient, it was actually something of a rite of passage back then to be able to run in a straight line across the zone. Also for PvP, being in such a dark area when coming out of MM adds an interesting dynamic. So it's definitely not a bad zone at all, it added mystery and danger to that area of the game, even if it could have included more content.

Originally Posted by Loke [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I'm going to go off script and say North Karana. If it didn't have the portals and serve as a link between the other Karanas, there would be almost no reason to ever go there. Super generic zone that offers basically nothing except access to other zones.

People hunted in North Karana in classic, because of the decent amount of wandering mobs that could be found within a close enough proximity. The gypsy quest for greater lightstones is here too and that was one of the very best ways to generate cash.

Originally Posted by Legday [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

How is West Karana not running away with this?

West Karana is a very good zone, the bandits and scarecrows and giants and ogres were all constantly camped, also the guards from Qeynos at the towers, LOL! The expansive size of the zone did a lot to create a feeling of Antonica being a realistically difficult continent to travel across, and the open plainsland with all the farms gave a sense of this being where the "common people" of the western world lived.

The constant river to the south and the hills/forrests to north, where the bandits and scary creatures roamed, created a cool feeling too, of varied topography and evil lurking that posed a constant danger to the common man. There was a werewolf that ran around terrorizing players too!

Granted, I will say the East half of this zone could have been more interesting. Everything I just talked about was in the West half. Even in that regard though, it mirrors trying to drive across the United States. Ever been through Kansas? It's nothing but endless flatland. So okay, I would have liked to see more in the zone still, I've always wanted it to be more possible for groups to just roam around a zone like this, killing monsters a method of exping/adventuring (which would greatly benefit Rangers as being beneficial to track things), but this zone was VERY important to the game.

[Schaduwridder]

karanas are peaceful and fun and have cool music in little sections.

karanas are everquest, if you don't like karanas you probably don't even like EQ

[AkashicRecord]

Originally Posted by Schaduwridder [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

karanas are peaceful and fun and have cool music in little sections.

karanas are everquest, if you don't like karanas you probably don't even like EQ

Western Karana:

You can listen to an entire ~70 minute DJ mix and not even be close to reaching a zone line.

The Ancient Cyclops spawns at least twice in other zones before you finish crossing this one.

It's the only zone where you can *actually* see the paint drying.

[AkashicRecord]

Western Karana:

The only thing that takes longer is waiting for one of the fucking boats.