Server Return

[Agaron]

Originally Posted by Beau [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I don't see the problem with boxing two characters. It doesn't ruin anything, It's just another way to enjoy the game, and "classic" eq allowed it i bought a second account in early 2000. I understand the rules on this server and I'm not trying to get them changed (im actually having a blast on just one) I just think its silly when people complain about something so transparent as playing 2 toons instead of one. I can understand when you are running MQ and botting an entire group, yeah thats a little silly, and really only serves farming, but there are a lot of times being able to log into just two accounts is very useful and actually quite fun. Whatever though just my 2 cents.

Plain and simple... buffs = pl'n/farming = kills groups + kills economy. Just because you get banned for selling game items for real money doesn't mean it won't happen quietly. 2, 3, 4, 5 boxing would make it so much easier to farm. Look at WoW.

[Beau]

True agaron, but really if you wanted to sell items quietly you really dont need more than one account to do that. I think Jilena put it best with "taking up more bandwidth and server resources." I guess my point was boxing two characters never "ruined" a server in eq live, which is what ive seen a few people say. In fact it kept eq alive because unlike here, when you boxed there you actually had to pay to use those resources. Using wow as a reference is kinda moot. People boxed full groups in eq classic and sold items from very early on long before wow. For most people in the community it was in fact pretty transparent. But rest assured as long as people are getting free service on this account i support 1 account per person 100%. I just didnt consider the limited resources before it makes a lot of sense, thanks jilena.

[maultar]

If you were limited to 2 accts to box and you always accepted others to group with you, that would solve the social aspect and possible hogging a camp. But hard to police that. I was going to ask that but came up with the answer on my own. Do I get a gold star?

[Thorjorkill]

Originally Posted by Beau [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

True agaron, but really if you wanted to sell items quietly you really dont need more than one account to do that. I think Jilena put it best with "taking up more bandwidth and server resources." I guess my point was boxing two characters never "ruined" a server in eq live, which is what ive seen a few people say. In fact it kept eq alive because unlike here, when you boxed there you actually had to pay to use those resources. Using wow as a reference is kinda moot. People boxed full groups in eq classic and sold items from very early on long before wow. For most people in the community it was in fact pretty transparent. But rest assured as long as people are getting free service on this account i support 1 account per person 100%. I just didnt consider the limited resources before it makes a lot of sense, thanks jilena.

I'll agree they never ruined a server, they however have ruined economies, and the social aspects (which are everything in EQ) At what point do we say STOP rule wise? My son and I both have accounts here, we come from the same top level IP and have an exception, but people playing two, three, four accounts by themselves? If the server admins slack up there, whats next? Bots? 1? 2? MQ? its a snowball, period.

Also, its the rules that count, not the "spirit" of the rules here. I know some posters here that say they don't have a problem with boxing, there is nothing wrong with it, and we should cut people a break. Ignorance of the rules is no excuse, and those that get banned, absolutely deserve it, regardless of wether or not you feel its right or wrong.

[Bones]

Originally Posted by Beau [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I don't see the problem with boxing two characters. It doesn't ruin anything, It's just another way to enjoy the game, and "classic" eq allowed it i bought a second account in early 2000. I understand the rules on this server and I'm not trying to get them changed (im actually having a blast on just one)

There are sooooooooooooooooooo many reasons why 2 boxing ruins the game that I don't even feel like listing them all for the 100th time.
Edit: Thought I would add this just real quick - A few people people 2 boxing would not ruin the server, no. But on live, not everybody 2 boxed either. This is an emu, and it is free. You allow 2 boxing and everybody and their mom will have cleric bots (or some other bot char just to make shit easier for themselves.)

Originally Posted by Beau [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I just think its silly when people complain about something so transparent as playing 2 toons instead of one. I can understand when you are running MQ and botting an entire group, yeah thats a little silly, and really only serves farming, but there are a lot of times being able to log into just two accounts is very useful and actually quite fun. Whatever though just my 2 cents.

This is classic. You can pretty much do the same shit with only 2 characters that you could do with a 6 botted group. (aside from raid content)
Example. You are a warrior. You want a FBSS. There is no way in hell you would be able to solo that camp. If there was 2 boxing, you could just log in a cleric bot instead of finding people to come join and help you.
Some people would be nice enough to invite people anyways. But most would be selfish enough to just hold the camp for hours and hours because they want that FBSS drop all to themselves.

I know there are classes that can solo and do this too. But with 2 boxing, anybody at all could, instead of the few high lvl chanters and necros on the server that can.

Basically, some people have legitimate reasons for wanting to 2 box. However, too many people would take advantage of it to fill their own selfish desires.

[jilena]

Another thing to consider is that live had a LOT more casual and/or less nerdy players back in the day. This server would have a LOT higher percentage of people boxing than a classic live server where it was a rarity. I know that if I personally could do this I would never group with any melee char I wanted to level, I'd just have level a druid to 50 to first and PL/Box them all to 50 without even once setting foot in a group.

Even discounting server resources and bandwidth you talking about raping the shit out of low-mid level content. 1 druid+whatever they are PLing can take chunks of MM for instance that usually would occupy 6-12 players. There are usually 3-4 people doing this on any given day currently across the whole server. How much open low-mid level content would there be if you had 50+ people doing that at any given time? *shrug*

I believe the devs had posted that boxing would be looked into if the server pop ever dropped so low that it became more of a necessity. Right now though unless you play in the wee wee hours it's not too bad finding groups at any level.

[grindle]

Wow 37 pages lol well back on topic ...really looking forward to the server being back up [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

[rioisk]

If two boxing were allowed then I can guarantee a large majority of the server would box. I assume only the hardcore/very interested players of classic EQ are on this server and this population of people know the benefits of boxing. As previously pointed out, a single person could two box and hold the camp to any non-raid spawn all to themselves. Further, what incentive do these people have to group? Given the option of controlling two characters or depending on some flaky cleric or shittily-equiped tank, people would choose to box. It's the most rational/optimal decision to maximize leveling-speed/farming speed/seeing content/etc.

I'm sure those who have a core group of friends, family members, etc playing would disagree because ultimately a single player can't play two characters at the same time as well as two players playing a single character each assuming similar levels of skill. However, not everybody has that luxury of close friends/family/dependable group-mates. In most cases, boxing comes the norm.

This destroys the social aspect of the game because boxing promotes a solo-experience.

[Nedala]

The big difference is you had to pay 2 accounts for 2-boxing at live servers; thats why the majority didnt 2-box.

On p99 the majority would probably 2-box because you dont have to pay any accounts. There much more reasons to not allow it on p99.

Funny how this discussion went from Server return to /ooc to exp bonus to 2-boxing [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

About the 25% exp: yes only few voted but there was so much crying about the 50% so the GMs decided to do something everybody could live with; We now have exp bonus but not that big, i think should be ok for everyone, its a good compromise.

[bigforest]

I'm not opposed to the bonus because 50% and 25% are negligible figures that will ultimately make very little difference.

With that in mind, my question is - why bother with the bonus at all?

I can't imagine it will bring additional players - in fact, I believe the server will be at record pop on Friday and Saturday already, bonus or not.

Maybe to make sure that everybody who logs on when the server returns stays with the community because they have a slightly higher level character than they would without the bonus? But then, what happens when it exp rate is back to normal?

I just can't quite grasp it.