If only DKP were tradable.

[magnetaress]

Originally Posted by Loke [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

So a combination of delusion and revisionist history.. nice. Have fun with your new guild.

My intention wasn't to troll Nexii.

For what it's worth. It sounds like AMs dkp wasn't worth much and neither is Freedoms.

Now ppl will invest in another guild.

[Nexii]

FWIW Riot isn't great either, but for different reasons.

[Fammaden]

Originally Posted by Nexii [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

FWIW Riot isn't great either, but for different reasons.

What reasons, I'm genuinely curious.

[Aadill]

There always seems to be a fundamental misunderstanding when people have negative perceptions of another entity and it's clear to me that there are some fundamental misunderstandings in regards to Freedom in this thread.

I'll just stick to the DKP one for now:

As someone who assisted in the math for the DKP transfers, I can attest to the fact that we squished the top end of the DKP numbers and raised the tail for everyone that was going to start with little to nothing at a reasonable amount so no one was left empty-handed. Using the data we had available that spanned from AM through AG, we predicted values for what made sense for the start of the new system. 150 got you a third to a half of a Ring 10, a BIS Vindi BP, a significant number of TOV items, and was more than a reasonable amount of DKP that if you did any amount of work in the guild you could easily jet up the ranks within a month or two. We regularly inspect our DKP structure to ensure we aren't suffering from major inflation, which thus far has been pretty well managed. Is it perfect? no, but it is a system that within just a few months we see a pretty good distribution of DKP earnt/spent that is normalized through the membership.

[Pint]

I founded AM and I didn't get 150dkp, where do I channel my feels

[hobart]

Originally Posted by Pint [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I founded AM and I didn't get 150dkp, where do I channel my feels

If that name was your idea, you owe so many people apologies.

[Nexii]

Originally Posted by Aadill [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

There always seems to be a fundamental misunderstanding when people have negative perceptions of another entity and it's clear to me that there are some fundamental misunderstandings in regards to Freedom in this thread.

I'll just stick to the DKP one for now:

As someone who assisted in the math for the DKP transfers, I can attest to the fact that we squished the top end of the DKP numbers and raised the tail for everyone that was going to start with little to nothing at a reasonable amount so no one was left empty-handed. Using the data we had available that spanned from AM through AG, we predicted values for what made sense for the start of the new system. 150 got you a third to a half of a Ring 10, a BIS Vindi BP, a significant number of TOV items, and was more than a reasonable amount of DKP that if you did any amount of work in the guild you could easily jet up the ranks within a month or two. We regularly inspect our DKP structure to ensure we aren't suffering from major inflation, which thus far has been pretty well managed. Is it perfect? no, but it is a system that within just a few months we see a pretty good distribution of DKP earnt/spent that is normalized through the membership.

Yea that's all fine and no one expects a 100% transfer for those reasons. 100% would mean no new players would enter the guild due to the old school players having insurmountable DKP. However the 0% offer wasn't fair either. From my perspective, Jestuh had that kind of hopelessly insurmountable lead.

[Aadill]

Originally Posted by Nexii [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Yea that's all fine and no one expects a 100% transfer for those reasons. 100% would mean no new players would enter the guild due to the old school players having insurmountable DKP. However the 0% offer wasn't fair either. From my perspective, Jestuh had that kind of hopelessly insurmountable lead.

If you were actually getting 0, I can't speak to that. But, if it was 150, it wasn't 0. It's a huge gap between Jestuh's points and 150, sure. But, there are people that started around the 300-400 mark, who have lower raid attendance than Jestuh, and within five months including spending 800-900 DKP are above where Jestuh started. This means that player has just as much ability to spend as Jestuh could at the beginning, which will buy nearly any item in our guild as Loke ponited out. Maybe that's an outlier, but it's not a hopeless venture, especially if you consider yourself an active raider. That's the same thing everyone feels when they join a raid guild and start from the bottom, but our bottom was not 0, meaning you had something to spend. Whether or not you can actually close the gap between Jestuh is a different story, but he's looking for only two or three items in the game and you can be sure that whatever he spends it will not keep him in the lead for very long.

Considering our approach was a combination of equality and equity adjustments I think we did a decent job and I'm sorry you don't feel that way about it.

[Nexii]

If no one makes you an offer then the offer is zero

[karadin]

Originally Posted by Nexii [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

If no one makes you an offer then the offer is zero

Yikes. I guess you wanted some special treatment that wasn’t afforded to any other soul in the game then. I wasn’t offered anything either by your standards, yet here we are.