Are we allowed to like AI art?

[Ekco]

i let Gemini chew on it

Whether we have discovered all genres of music is a deeply philosophical question with no definitive answer, but it's highly unlikely. The creation of new genres is an ongoing process, not a finite one. It's less about being "too busy" and more about the natural evolution of music as a reflection of culture, technology, and social movements. Genres aren't discovered; they emerge from the blending of existing styles, technological innovation, and new cultural contexts.

The eight "pillars" Chat GPT outlined are more like major historical movements rather than an exhaustive list of all genres. They represent broad, foundational shifts in how music is created, distributed, and consumed. While they're valid and influential, they're not the end of the story.

The "Pillars" as Revolutions
Chat GPT's reasoning about the eight pillars is based on the idea of musical revolutions. This is a solid way to think about it. For example, the invention of the electric guitar was a technological revolution that directly led to rock & roll. Similarly, the widespread availability of turntables and samplers was a technological revolution that gave birth to hip-hop.

Symphonic / Classical: The formalization of Western music theory and instrumentation.

American Song & Blues: The fusion of African and European musical traditions.

Jazz: The revolutionary use of improvisation and syncopation.

Rock & Roll: The embrace of electric instrumentation and youth rebellion.

Folk / Songwriting: The focus on personal narrative and lyrical authenticity.

Soul / Funk / Disco: The emphasis on rhythm, dance, and a strong beat.

Hip-Hop: The creative use of sampling, looping, and the spoken word.

Electronic / Techno / House: The use of machines and synthesizers as the primary creative tool.

This list isn't about specific genres like shoegaze, lo-fi, or vaporwave, but about the big-picture shifts that made those genres possible.

A Ninth Pillar?
Thinking of a ninth pillar is a great way to push this concept forward. Chat GPT's suggestion of AI/interactive music is compelling because it focuses on a technological paradigm shift, similar to how previous pillars were defined.

An alternative or complementary candidate for a ninth pillar could be Global Fusion / World Music. While it's not a single genre, it represents a global revolution in music creation and consumption. Historically, Western music has been seen as the dominant force, but with the internet and globalization, there has been an unprecedented blending of sounds from around the world. Artists now freely incorporate traditional instruments, rhythms, and vocal styles from different cultures in a way that goes beyond the "exotic" influences seen in earlier eras. This isn't just a subgenre; it's a fundamental shift in how musicians access, share, and incorporate diverse musical ideas. This pillar is defined by the democratization of global sounds.

An actual ninth pillar could be a combination of AI and Global Fusion, where AI tools are used to facilitate and accelerate the blending of global musical traditions, creating entirely new, culturally-rich soundscapes.

Your point about AI is spot-on; it's already creating entirely new forms of music. Whether it's the next great pillar will depend on how fundamentally it changes the way we create and consume music, similar to how the turntable and sampler did for hip-hop.

[shovelquest]

Originally Posted by Ekco [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

i let Gemini chew on it

That's great.

But to its conclusion, it does end by blending (formerly new) genera's together, not really inventing a new genera in itself.

It mentioned the invention of the electric guitar.

And I've thought about that too, that some of these genera's and pillars kind of were reliant on a type of instrument.

And maybe if a new instrument is invented we might see a new genera. But with all the sounds I've ever heard in my life I can't help but think that I will be like, "this is just rock and roll with a flute."

I bet gen alpha will say rock and roll done by AI is a new genera and argue with me that im too old to understand.

[Ekco]

it's gonna come down to a user input, need some crazy fucks like jethro thule, primus, frank zappa type fucks

the computers aren't gonna do it themselves.