Taken - Sev

[Lanuven]

Wheres Fearstalker been? It seems sad to think that this guild who used to be somewhat decent is now harboring such people as Catherin and still holding an officer title of the guild. I guess this goes to show you what their MO is now. Surely they will keep on keeping on if they continue to get verbal warnings at best.

[Exmo]

I still think the best Analogy to this situation is the BDA Suspension for Peeling off what BDA thought was a Stall without allowing the mob (CT? Draco? I don't remember) to reset.

BDA was rightfully suspended and the GM's arguement was that, even if it was a stall, BDA wasn't allowed to make that call, and should never kill anything without an FTE Message. So the Illegal Pull by a tracker doesn't matter. The kill without an FTE Shout should mean a suspension.

[Ravager]

Any guesses on how this will be ruled next time it happens?

[sulpher01]

Originally Posted by Exmo [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I still think the best Analogy to this situation is the BDA Suspension for Peeling off what BDA thought was a Stall without allowing the mob (CT? Draco? I don't remember) to reset.

BDA was rightfully suspended and the GM's arguement was that, even if it was a stall, BDA wasn't allowed to make that call, and should never kill anything without an FTE Message. So the Illegal Pull by a tracker doesn't matter. The kill without an FTE Shout should mean a suspension.

Basically this sums it up.. same situation plus a bunch of onlookers and some how the onlookers makes it OK?

So pull whatever you want if there's a bunch of people there.

[Relbaic]

Originally Posted by Exmo [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I still think the best Analogy to this situation is the BDA Suspension for Peeling off what BDA thought was a Stall without allowing the mob (CT? Draco? I don't remember) to reset.

BDA was rightfully suspended and the GM's arguement was that, even if it was a stall, BDA wasn't allowed to make that call, and should never kill anything without an FTE Message. So the Illegal Pull by a tracker doesn't matter. The kill without an FTE Shout should mean a suspension.

Draco, but I guess that part of it doesn't really matter. The lack of consistency in the rulings is pretty appalling though.

[Thana8088]

Now come on guys, you weren't there and you don't know what really happened.

Oh wait, yes we do....

[AnOldEnemy]

15 years later, 3 years of kunark later people still take this shit this seriously?

[Wrench]

Originally Posted by Lanuven [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Wheres Fearstalker been?

honestly was just about to post this exact question

[Eponymous Anonymous]

Fearstalker's got this new thing called a "real life"... y'all should look into it.

[Duckwalk]

Go outside?!?

*insert joke about P99 raiding community being unable to simutaneously collect government welfare and deny pixel welfare*