Raid competition or not?

[eqravenprince]

Originally Posted by loramin [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Yeah, as I said I know the sample size is low, but the thing is I was expecting 15 to 0 or maybe 14 to 1; definitely wasn't expecting to see 7 to 9.

I agree. I am glad I am not the only one that voted no.

[Chrimes]

Raid scene sux, but its driven by honest competition. Change nothing > making competition useless

[Daldaen]

Leave competition in the end-game. IE VP.

Rotate the open world dragons, Trakanon, VS.

[oddibemcd]

Everquest is pretty close to a perfect democracy. If you have more of XXX (time, lvl 60 toons, gear) you are going to succeed 100% of the time.

I think I and the people who voted no would prefer something closer to proportional representation.

If guild A has 100 members that average 40 hours a week, that's 4,000 man hours.

If guild B has 50 members that average 20 hours a week, that's 1,000 man hours.

Currently, guild A gets very close to 100% of the targets under a democratic process.

Under proportional representation, guild B would get 1 target to every 4 that guild A gets. I think that's why it's almost 50% for each option.