Noble Dojorn Timers

[Hyjal]

Honestly, I think farming noble by keeping a ton of OOR's alive is a cheap way to obtain loot.


And you want to GM enforce this? Because its a cheap way to obtain loot?

[bktroost]

Originally Posted by Hyjal [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Honestly, I think farming noble by keeping a ton of OOR's alive is a cheap way to obtain loot.


And you want to GM enforce this? Because its a cheap way to obtain loot?

I think this comment might be a little Out Of Range of this topic. I can't say I even understand what the term "a cheap way to obtain loot" means. Maybe you could elaborate on your point and explain what moralistic view Dolj has on generating more Nobles.

[Argh]

We can reach an OOA agreement without reaching an agreement for rotating Nobles or a YDYN agreement.

Having more nobles is better for everyone regardless of how you wish to treat them (FTE clickfest, rotation, YDYN, etc.)

[Hyjal]

That's like saying re-popping all dragons and gods on the server every day is good for the server because everyone gets loot. Well, its not.

A player agreement seems reasonable. Asking GM's to enforce it so everyone can farm the hell out of it doesn't seem to be. Legit? Sure. But damn, how easy do you want it?

[Hyjal]

Nobody happy until 13 nobles a day are popping? or however many guilds there are? Gimmie a break...

This shouldn't even be a topic.

[Argh]

GMs have already agreed to enforce it if we all agree to terms of the punishment for breaking it.

[-Catherin-]

No point in trying to reason with Lord Bob. They will continue to FTE without logic or fairness.

Don't really need them as part of the agreement anyways. They still havnt even legally killed a raid mob yet right?

[bktroost]

Originally Posted by -Catherin- [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

No point in trying to reason with Lord Bob. They will continue to FTE without logic or fairness.

Don't really need them as part of the agreement anyways. They still haven't even legally killed a raid mob yet right?

Well here is an interesting point. Is Genocidal Tendencies or that Baker's Guild on the raid roster? No, because they haven't legally killed anything. Should Cats Who Say Meow have a decision in how IB and TMO handle FTEs and training in VP? Probably not. Should that trading guild in EC have a seat on the committee that decides Noble agreements? Doubtful, since they aren't a raiding guild.

Every major raiding guild has agreed to this arrangement and it would appear that a guild that does not successfully raid major targets is trying to strong arm the server for misbegotten moralistic reasons. I question the legitimacy of this claim. Do we need to try to coerce Lord Bob to see reason or does their argument not hold weight against 99% of the successful raiding guilds?

[Pint]

I'm doubting that hyjal speaks for his guild on this matter, I imagine he didn't even consult them. I'd say let him run his mouth and see where he ends up, looks like the final nail in the bob coffin to me.

[jpetrick]

Originally Posted by jpetrick [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Indignation agrees to rotate nobles amongst guilds, with no OOAs being killed. We are against your day your noble due to guilds sharing a sky day creating complications for a different system.