[Serious] Lets talk Top raiding guilds and their behavior

[MarauderOHHYEAH]

Originally Posted by Baler [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Rotations kill server population. On paper it looks great, oh boy a fair chance at some raid loot. But in practice it hurts the servers population.

It's not the answer, TAKP does rotations and raiders only log in when it's their turn to kill a target.

New players will have a harder time finding group because the overall pop will be lower. There are multiple bad endings to a rotation this is just one of them.

ps. I use to be for rotations until I saw the affect they have on a servers population. I can't say this enough.

I'm not arguing the point but do you have data to back up the stance?

Thats pretty much how p99 is now is why I ask... pop days have much higher numbers than others

[Baler]

Originally Posted by MarauderOHHYEAH [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Thats pretty much how p99 is now is why I ask... pop days have much higher numbers than others

That is not how P99 is now. Multiple guilds log in to try and FTE for a target in a competitive and large scale fashion. You could have 200+ people in 1 zone on p99 across multiple guilds.

With a rotation you won't even have half that number. There is no reason for any other guild to be online if it's not their turn to kill the target.

---
I agree to a point, there are some people who play p99 that only log on for raiding. But they do not factor into the best solution formula because they fall into the rotation flaws category as well.

[MarauderOHHYEAH]

I mean... there's the game...

At most we would lose 160ish? On pop days? I think that's how many rito or ag/f have

I'm against serverwide rotations btw

[Psyborg]

Rotations also kill the need for a lot of the raiding infrastructure that requires people to log in during the week. Alts/bots, idols, scepters, plat for recharges, etc. All that stuff goes away or is largely made redundant with rotations. I wish Riot would just drop that altogether from their proposal.

[Baler]

Technically your guild agreeing to a player agreement is binding.
So in a sense, they could be seen as rules. Once the staff put a player agreement in place.

But they are not set in stone like the rules and pnp are. Rules and the PNP are the backbone. These player agreements are a requirement for adults to play nicely together.

[Dreenk317]

Originally Posted by Baler [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Technically your guild agreeing to a player agreement is binding.
So in a sense, they could be seen as rules. Once the staff put a player agreement in place.

But they are not set in stone like the rules and pnp are. Rules and the PNP are the backbone. These player agreements are a requirement for adults to play nicely together.

its been made clear, i feel, that the GM's are not holding you to the agreement after youve entered it though. As in, you can remove yourself from it with proper notice. And, no guild other than AG/F/R has to agree to this agreement that they are coming up with.

[MarauderOHHYEAH]

Originally Posted by Baler [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Technically your guild agreeing to a player agreement is binding.
So in a sense, they could be seen as rules. Once the staff put a player agreement in place.

But they are not set in stone like the rules and pnp are. Rules and the PNP are the backbone. These player agreements are a requirement for adults to play nicely together.

[MarauderOHHYEAH]

They are also coming up with new rules that will be in place when these rotations and agreements inevitably fail... those are what we want a say in

[Ripqozko]

Originally Posted by MarauderOHHYEAH [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

They are also coming up with new rules that will be in place when these rotations and agreements inevitably fail... those are what we want a say in

You voted for Biden

[MarauderOHHYEAH]

Originally Posted by Ripqozko [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

You voted for Biden

I'm voting for a meteor