Name Change is in Order

[Samoht]

Originally Posted by Humerox [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

The way Holocaust used it on R99 does not.

You can't prove the intent. You're not even in the guild according to your signature. Your purpose here is strictly to play devil's advocate. The fact remains that the meaning is ambiguous and it offends a party through one of the many definitions to that ambiguity, so a name change is certainly in order to remove that ambiguity. Fier`Dal Holocaust, PK Holocaust, Fat-race Holocaust, all clearly separate themselves from the Holocaust.

Note: Red Holocaust is going to be just as unacceptable.

[loopholbrook]

Just backing way up to the "google it" thing. I googled "hottest chick on earth" and this is what came up. Everything you google isn't necessarily true. [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.] [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

[pickled_heretic]

Originally Posted by loopholbrook [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Just backing way up to the "google it" thing. I googled "hottest chick on earth" and this is what came up. Everything you google isn't necessarily true. [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.] [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

How far did you have to dig to find that? Because I just googled the same thing and I haven't found anything that is even remotely unfuckable.

[loopholbrook]

Originally Posted by pickled_heretic [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

How far did you have to dig to find that? Because I just googled the same thing and I haven't found anything that is even remotely unfuckable.

Second page on images? You can't find two pictures out of twenty?

[pickled_heretic]

Originally Posted by loopholbrook [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Second page on images? You can't find two pictures out of twenty?

When you search for "hottest chick on earth" do you find mostly results of hot chicks? or, do you find mostly pictures of old grandmas and teenage boys? What is your opinion of the consensus?

[loopholbrook]

Originally Posted by pickled_heretic [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

When you search for "hottest chick on earth" do you find mostly results of hot chicks? or, do you find mostly pictures of old grandmas and teenage boys? What is your opinion of the consensus?

Okay, I'll use your own argument against you. When you google "hottest chick on earth" do you find the same girl, or do you find hundreds of different women? Obviously they can't all be THE hottest chick on earth.

[Humerox]

dig a little deeper and you'll see yhay Vanessa redgrave was once indeed, a hottie.

[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

[Knuckle]

this guild is ruining my immersion, please change name to Zion Movement

[loopholbrook]

To pickled_heretic I noticed that when I trumped you, you just ignored me. Just to clarify that the majority sees no need to change, I went through every page and here is a list of who wants change and who doesn't want change.
For change: 1. Aruden 2. pickled_heretic 3. xshayla701 4. mitic 5. Samoht
Against change: 1.Nilbog 2. Truth 3. Knuckle 4. purest 5. Diggles 6. Supreme 7. bionicbadger 8. Loopholbrook 9. Lazortag 10. Humerox 11. Uthgaard 12. Karrmer 13. Hasbinbad 14. doors 15. Grahm 16. Vinicito 17. Rust1d 18. Barkingturtle 19. Glitch 20. Hailto 21. dcapotos 22. Szeth 23. Maurk 24. Kornaki 25. Autotune

In conclusion, this thread has a 5:1 ratio for no change. That's an overwhelming majority of people who think that five people on the server are butt hurt. Name stays, /thread.

[pickled_heretic]

Originally Posted by loopholbrook [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

To pickled_heretic I noticed that when I trumped you, you just ignored me. Just to clarify that the majority sees no need to change, I went through every page and here is a list of who wants change and who doesn't want change.
For change: 1. Aruden 2. pickled_heretic 3. xshayla701 4. mitic 5. Samoht
Against change: 1.Nilbog 2. Truth 3. Knuckle 4. purest 5. Diggles 6. Supreme 7. bionicbadger 8. Loopholbrook 9. Lazortag 10. Humerox 11. Uthgaard 12. Karrmer 13. Hasbinbad 14. doors 15. Grahm 16. Vinicito 17. Rust1d 18. Barkingturtle 19. Glitch 20. Hailto 21. dcapotos 22. Szeth 23. Maurk 24. Kornaki 25. Autotune

In conclusion, this thread has a 5:1 ratio for no change. That's an overwhelming majority of people who think that five people on the server are butt hurt. Name stays, /thread.

You didn't trump anything. This thread has been a resounding success from my perspective, from Uthgaard grammar nazi self-owning himself completely out of the thread, to softening positions of some of the more intelligent detractors (such as Lazortag) who have posted here. I largely consider the "U SUK QQ MOAR NOOB" posts to be irrelevant and I have ignored them.

Objectively speaking, the majority is irrelevant to guild naming policy. the only people's opinions who matter are Nilbog's, Rogean's, and whoever else is responsible for the guild naming policy on this server. Just because they currently don't agree with my perspective doesn't mean that they can't be persuaded. From a "classic" perspective I'm pretty sure a guild name like this would have never made it on live. What other criteria do they use?