Should I give this guy my Fishbone Earring?

[georgie]

what do I look like a MT?

[khysanth]

Consider phinny

[mrquincy]

It seems that OP beat you to Hadden because they had the timer. Since OP acquired the earring because they had the timer, Eivy should use OP's kill to start his or her own timer. This gives Eivy the same opportunity that led to OP's success.

Rules exist for a reason, and that reason is that "nice" is subjective, as evidenced here over and over again. It seems like "lawyer-questing" is a way to trivialize the utility of rules. Rules are useful.

[JackFlash]

Has anyone even camped hadden? The only way to get him is by having the timer or sitting there until he spawns and hope you don't have to afk. In which case you will deal with people who do have the timer logging in right when he spawns. I always just sit right on his spawn point and make sure people know I'm there. Otherwise you're screwed. Been this way for years here..... I've also seen the same farmers locking up the spawn for weeks on end. Like Eivy.....

[Domo]

If both of you want to end this topic fast, do a /random 0 100

[Paleman]

you know guys this is a pretty important pivotal case in norrathian courts. It will make legal precedence for future camp stealing cases.

But do you think it will make it up to kangaroo court?

[Pokesan]

azeth flexin nuts on cecily

[azeth]

i really am not though. its just how the fucking island works!

[azeth]

seafury isle makes its way to RNF once again.

the year? 2016

[BallzDeep]

Delete the fishbone earring. This is the only solution. Then both of you proceed to camp it again. Who ever wins must delete the fishbone earring again. This is fair punishment for both of you.