What is the hardest dungeon in the game?

[Drosis]

Also, Dragon Necropolis is a close second for hardest dungeon.

[mickmoranis]

ok well since i was able to get a nerriad shawl with my shaman who has 2k hp then SG is an easy zone.

[mickmoranis]

Is it though? Im not arguing, im asking.

What group-able content is difficult to obtain there, vs what is just impossible to obtain because its just not 'groupable' unless you've been farming velious for a few years?

I have gotten that snake a few times with like 5 or 6 people, with 1 person kiting the zone around etc, i would say that is hard becuse you have to learn the strategy to do it.

But most people I know can pull that snake to the zoneline by themselves somehow, idk.

But those rats were easy to farm, with little threat really. Tons of safe spots to camp out rezzers and stuff too make me kind of on the fence for this one (there is also a safe spot in SG infront of the castle to do this, there is none in west that I could find or east of HS...

idk i still think pound for pound HS is a harder dungeon, its lower level than SG for sure, and DN, but I could be convinced because of lack of experience in DN that DN may be harder, idk.

[fadetree]

Blackburrow, when we wore patchwork. Before the walls fell. Hodor.

[Tecmos Deception]

Originally Posted by fadetree [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Blackburrow, when we wore patchwork. Before the walls fell. Hodor.

Shaka, when the walls fell?

[mickmoranis]

Originally Posted by Tecmos Deception [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Shaka, when the walls fell?

Dar Ghoul and jibaner at The Tangrin, when the lev faded.

[pasi]

To add to the SG-fiesta and toss a bone to any Kedge supporters.

Live EQ's water mechanics were a shitload worse compared to P99. You didn't see shit in water unless you skimmed the top of the water or used the rear-view inventory window.

[easy_lee]

Regarding Dalnir, it's tough, but doable. Breaking the camps and figuring out a strategy is the hard part. It mostly overwhelms people due to their lack of experience with it.

For the casters downstairs, any party with two fast melees can handle these if they know how. On my monk, duo'd the whole bottom floor (aside from boss, because screw that) in low 40's (mobs were blue). If you dual wield and stand right on the casters' toes, you can push them back and interrupt their casting. When they don't get spells off, they don't hit hard enough to be a threat. We kept up that duo pulling nonstop for about four hours, and both got a crescent set (legs take the longest to drop).

The casters are the hardest part about the zone, so it's all about having a counter for them.

[Alanus]

If we are going by level appropriateness:

Mid-level: Dalnir by far. So many casters. So many SKs with HT. Only way out is to deeper in, where Kly Overseer will beat the snot out of you. However, you can invis through pretty easily. But if we are talking level-appropriate group, Dalnir is never done for a good reason.

Honorable mention of Paw. Lots of casters and healers with intense mob density once you get past the double door. There's safe pull areas, but very difficult zone. A mid 30s group could probably do just fine, but it'd be difficult. If you forget to snare a mob, your group is dead

High-level: Siren's Grotto. Not talking about zone in areas (which are no cake walk), but farther in, the sirens. Single pulling is impossible. If you want to clear the temple area, you need at least 3-4 well equipped groups. On live, we used to do it as a guild to farm BP gems and we were a competent raid guild. One bad pull and we would have severe issues, even with 5-6 groups. It was bad. Charming mobs and trash mobs that AE for 500 with dispell.

Dragon Necropolis gets honorable mention, because of the chetari caves. A single group could certainly do this, but it's not easy. Tons of mobs in a small area. Traps are annoying.

Howling stones is not even in the same league as DN and SG. A single SG trash mob could probably take out Drusella and could possibly solo most camps there.

[easy_lee]

Originally Posted by Alanus [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Mid-level: Dalnir by far. So many casters. So many SKs with HT. Only way out is to deeper in, where Kly Overseer will beat the snot out of you. However, you can invis through pretty easily. But if we are talking level-appropriate group, Dalnir is never done for a good reason.

I think the main reason why it's never done is lack of interest. Why bother when there are giants right next door that are easier, closer to vendors, and drop more plat? Crescent set is no drop, and there aren't many other useful drops in the zone. It's mostly monk and necromancer stuff, and is totally optional on both counts. Even if you get a valuable drop, it'll probably take longer to drop than a greater amount of plat from giants.