Pixel Law - A Case Study

[booter]

some very non-classic raiding happening on this server

[skarlorn]

No thanks, not reading this litigationquest document

[bktroost]

Originally Posted by Ella`Ella [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

On September 25, during a normal course of respawns....

If Eashan was not up before the racers left the doorline it is considered a tracker FTE to tag Eashan and does immediately get disqualified.

This is unquestionably the rule despite common day tracking methods. No player may achieve a legitimate FTE on any mob without starting at the designated starting line. Beneficial or harmful to their interests, any FTE achieved in this way is disqualified and MUST be conceded.

Originally Posted by Ella`Ella [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

In a heated moment of anticipation, Aaryonar spawned and the runners fired off of the line. As the runners of <Patriots> and <Cucks> began to turn the corner just past the door to the North Wing, <Cucks> runner Lil’ Billy was met with the fury of Eashen of the Sky, triggering an FTE on behalf of <Cucks>

What we do not know from this description is whether or not Eashan was up before the racers left the line. That's the most relevant piece of data and it is missing from your description.

[Joyelle]

Originally Posted by bktroost [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

If Eashan was not up before the racers left the doorline it is considered a tracker FTE to tag Eashan and does immediately get disqualified.

This is unquestionably the rule despite common day tracking methods. No player may achieve a legitimate FTE on any mob without starting at the designated starting line. Beneficial or harmful to their interests, any FTE achieved in this way is disqualified and MUST be conceded.



What we do not know from this description is whether or not Eashan was up before the racers left the line. That's the most relevant piece of data and it is missing from your description.

Spot on, sir.

[Moosetoe]

Originally Posted by bktroost [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

If Eashan was not up before the racers left the doorline it is considered a tracker FTE to tag Eashan and does immediately get disqualified.

This is unquestionably the rule despite common day tracking methods. No player may achieve a legitimate FTE on any mob without starting at the designated starting line. Beneficial or harmful to their interests, any FTE achieved in this way is disqualified and MUST be conceded.



What we do not know from this description is whether or not Eashan was up before the racers left the line. That's the most relevant piece of data and it is missing from your description.

completely agree

Originally Posted by Ella`Ella [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

There is a policy in place that when multiple mobs are up, you call which mob you are going for so that if you get FTE from the other, it will not lock you in and you can continue for the chosen mob. This policy has been in place for some time and is observed by all guilds which directly avoids these situations.

Can you please show me where this is documented as being a policy? It's little "rules" like this that are NOT mentioned in the Project 1999 Raid Rules (updated 4/5/2016) that makes it very difficult for new players to enter, understand, and feel comfortable in the P99 raid scene, especially if being held accountable for "rules" that aren't on the go-to for understanding server rules.

[booter]

OBJECTION

[Cecily]

Originally Posted by booter [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

OBJECTION

[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

[FatMice]

Not using real names and guilds makes this thread useless. Prediction... thread dies by page 3.

[maskedmelon]

Obviously Cucks are wrong or they wouldn't be Cucks, duuhhhhuhuuuhhh.

Now, I have to say I am actually surprised to learn that what they did actually is wrong (obvious wrong because Cucks done it, but would not have guessed if others had done it). Crazy. Tyx for the erudition OP ^^

[booter]

it's not a policy, he just made it up to suit his position