Quest Issue: white training sash

[Leaching]

so I do not know if anyone else has done this. I seemed to have deleted my white training sash in hopes of getting another and more importantly the exp that would go with it. I can not do the quest again, turned in 2 scalps got text I was well on my way to getting one, hailed went through dialog turned in 2 more... got same text, still no sash. do i need to re-roll my monk?

[Arrisard]

Quest requires a total of 4 items to hand in; 2 (unstacked) Deathfist pawn scalps (not orc scalp), 1 bone chips, and 1 snake fang.