Asking a favor from the two top guilds on the server

[Tenlaar]

Originally Posted by Stalahoy [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

as a member of FE i would be open to rotations, as im pretty sure our entire guild has been from the formation of it. TMO the haters =P

Not according to posts from other members of FE in this thread. Unless by rotation you mean a rotation of the mobs that you decide you don't really need to kill any more but still will.

[Hurley]

Originally Posted by Tenlaar [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Not according to posts from other members of FE in this thread. Unless by rotation you mean a rotation of the mobs that you decide you don't really need to kill any more but still will.

TMO has held the end game under their thumb on this server and you understand we still need Trak to compete with them in VP right?

100% of our loot goes to members, not alts of the "good ol boys" club. Most of our guild needs epics and BiS gear still.

TMO kills mobs on the reg that goes strait to the guild bank.

[maverixdamighty]

Originally Posted by Tenlaar [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Not according to posts from other members of FE in this thread. Unless by rotation you mean a rotation of the mobs that you decide you don't really need to kill any more but still will.

there are lots of different types of rotations. i've openly stated i'm not a decision maker, but i think rotating everything isn't something we should do at this point. People want raid mobs then when you offer some up it's not enough...

[Tierael]

Originally Posted by maverixdamighty [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

there are lots of different types of rotations. i've openly stated i'm not a decision maker, but i think rotating everything isn't something we should do at this point. People want raid mobs then when you offer some up it's not enough...

The way I see it, there are only 8 targets that should even be discussed (the 8 I mentioned in my above idea). If you just leave it at that, I'm sure people would understand why a rotation won't include the others.

Naggy/Vox? Make an alt army and camp them there if you want it IMO.
PoSky? Not really...
Royals? Yael? Phinigel? Derp
VS/Trak/VP = FE/TMO priority #1 and rightly so

So is Fear/Hate/4dragons too much to share? Every week, TMO/FE would have 2 targets of 10 (if you add VS/Trak only) that they can't tag. That's 20% of the raid targets per week, again, not counting the obvious. And they aren't just giving these targets up to one guild in turn. They give them up for Div/Taken/BDA/FC/FV to have their OWN FTE races.

On top of this, I'm sure the lower guilds can put an agreement on top of all this, that none of us would take any 1 target twice in a row. If BDA got Faydedar on the first rotation pop, I would hope we would forgo the target next rotation.

[maverixdamighty]

Originally Posted by Tierael [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

The way I see it, there are only 8 targets that should even be discussed (the 8 I mentioned in my above idea). If you just leave it at that, I'm sure people would understand why a rotation won't include the others.

Naggy/Vox? Make an alt army and camp them there if you want it IMO.
PoSky? Not really...
Royals? Yael? Phinigel? Derp
VS/Trak/VP/CT/Inny/Sev = FE/TMO priority #1 and rightly so

added more that I would consider priorities. VP shouldn't be included as there are really only two guilds capable maybe a 3rd depending on how many keys BDA has.