Necro Soloing After Patch

[Hailto]

So, essentially enchanter charm soloing is fucking worthless now? What is the point of remaking mistakes that the classic EQ devs made and later fixed? That makes zero sense what so ever, nicely done.

[Kassel]

Originally Posted by Hailto [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

So, essentially enchanter charm soloing is fucking worthless now? What is the point of remaking mistakes that the classic EQ devs made and later fixed? That makes zero sense what so ever, nicely done.

This is the "lets get as close to classic as possible server" the "lets fix the dev's mistakes server" has yet to be created.

[mwatt]

Originally Posted by Kassel [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

This is the "lets get as close to classic as possible server" the "lets fix the dev's mistakes server" has yet to be created.

Well put.

I will add that it takes time to make all the necessary changes to the original code base that makes the server classic-like. That means some random asshat can always say, "Well this isn't classic so why even try to make anything classic?". Obviously, that is a nonsense question, and should never be used as justification for desired non-classic changes.

The other point that is sometimes made is, "This change was eventually reversed, so why even put it in place?". The problem with this point is that it is nearly impossible to draw the line. What if a change was made in 2011? Should we retro the game play p99? Probably not. What about 2005? Might make sense.... how to decide that? Which changes should be reversed and which should not? If ANY were reversed, would the server still be as close to classic as possible, within in the time frame that is currently being experienced there? No, it wouldn't.

What if a change (nerf) were reversed in Luclin? An argument could be made for that change to eventually occur in p99 I think. However, it would probably best occur after Velious had been in place for a while.

[pickled_heretic]

Originally Posted by mwatt [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Well put.

I will add that it takes time to make all the necessary changes to the original code base that makes the server classic-like. That means some random asshat can always say, "Well this isn't classic so why even try to make anything classic?". Obviously, that is a nonsense question, and should never be used as justification for desired non-classic changes.

you made this statement without explaining any reasons why. in light of certain things being intentionally non-classic (such as pet aggro and pet weapon delays, ivandy's hoop etc) could you please elucidate? thanks.

Originally Posted by Kassel [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

This is the "lets get as close to classic as possible server" the "lets fix the dev's mistakes server" has yet to be created.

we've already crossed the rubicon there. certain exploits like being able to make tradeskill items that sold to vendors for more than it cost to make them were never in this game in the first place. was the server better off for it? absolutely. doesn't change the fact that it wasn't classic.

[Extunarian]

Originally Posted by Hailto [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

So, essentially enchanter charm soloing is fucking worthless now? What is the point of remaking mistakes that the classic EQ devs made and later fixed? That makes zero sense what so ever, nicely done.

What? Just break charm before the mob you are killing dies.

[Rallyd]

I think you guys are kind of missing the point of the nerf, most people in classic didn't even know about it, mages still went along their way as one of the best solo exp classes in the game, necros who knew about it slaughtered the exp bar, and ones who didnt did fairly well still.

The point of it is that if you didn't know about it you wouldn't be so up in arms about it, that's why sony never told you until they fixed it, and anyone without MQ2 exp gain protocols didn't figure it out. Just go with it, regardless of getting 50% exp per mob, if you didn't know, you'd still be getting way better exp than 80% of the other classes :/