Shaman vs Enchanter

[Splorf22]

I would say enchanters and shamans are both excellent but with different twists. Necros and Mages are kind of the 'garden variety' soloers who take out single targets quickly and efficiently. Enchanters can take out large camps which would be impossible for any other class (e.g. the King in Lower Guk. If I ever get my char restored I'll probably play around with soloing Sebilis) while Shaman can handle very strong single targets which would be impossible for anyone else just because between slow and torpor they never die.

Part of the problem with the soloing enchanter is that the only thing between you and a massive beatdown is charm/mez/lull/stun/root. So no matter how good you are, if the RNG decides to give you 4 stun resists in a row, or a lull critical at a bad time, you're going to be a smear on the floor.

In XP groups I would give enchanters the edge if only because of clarity, but in raids shaman are more important for slow/malo while enchanters buffbot and maybe suicide themselves with tashan. Shaman probably have the edge in small groups because they can duo with melee classes quite effectively.

[Splorf22]

Necros manabattery the clerics.

The problem with enchanters is that our abilities are just too awesome. Imagine if you could actually mez Nagafen: you could fight him with 6 people down to 80%, then keep him mezzed while the cleric recovered, etc. Or if two enchanters could just chainstun him while a couple of rogues beat him down. Or if you could charm Nagafen and have him slaughter the BnB . . . I'm actually quite confident that if Boltrans went up to 55 I could solo a dragon (assuming TMO/TR would give me the chance).

[Splorf22]

Actually, I think it might be possible even with a L53 cap. According to the wiki, Warlord Skarlon has 19000 hp and hits for 175+, while Nagafen has 32000 hp and hits for 255. If we assume that Skarlon dual wields 80% of the time with Wondrous Rapidity (73% haste), and that both hit 75% of the time and DW 75% of the time, with an average hit for 75% of max:

Skarlon: 175 * 1.8 * 1.73 * 1.75 * 0.75 * 0.75 / 3 = 180 dps
Nagafen: 255 * 1.75 * 0.75 * 0.75 / 3 = 85 dps

So after three minutes Nagafen is dead and Skarlon is at 20% or so - of course this is ignoring Nagafen's AEs. A three minute charm of Skarlon would definitely be possible although no guarantee - it would take 5-10 attempts. Aside from the difficulty of killing all the other fire giants, binding down there, and dragging Skarlon over to Naggy.