How I group people into one of two categories.

[Feachie]

i like this thread. my first rpg was dragon warrior, got it with my nintendo power subscription in 1988.

my favorite rpg's in no particular order:
castlevania: sotn
secret of mana (seiken densetsu 2)
dragon quest
legend of dragoon
chrono cross (chrono trigger is yet another good but overrated game, glenn just happens to be my love)
d20 modern
blue dragon
ffiv
suikoden
and if we're considering ocarina of time an rpg...metal gear solid :P

final fantasy IV was my favorite final fantasy. VII was ok, but it's a cookie cutter squaresoft rpg at this point.
final fantasy 8, x2, 11, 12, 13...sucked. imo they lost what made the ff series final fantasy. square just needs to hire akira toriyama for their next rpg and stop trying to release huge cinematic events, just fucking make a good game.

[Autotune]

Originally Posted by Feachie [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

i like this thread. my first rpg was dragon warrior, got it with my nintendo power subscription in 1988.

my favorite rpg's in no particular order:
castlevania: sotn
secret of mana (seiken densetsu 2)
dragon quest
legend of dragoon
chrono cross (chrono trigger is yet another good but overrated game, glenn just happens to be my love)
d20 modern
blue dragon
ffiv
suikoden
and if we're considering ocarina of time an rpg...metal gear solid :P

final fantasy IV was my favorite final fantasy. VII was ok, but it's a cookie cutter squaresoft rpg at this point.
final fantasy 8, x2, 11, 12, 13...sucked. imo they lost what made the ff series final fantasy. square just needs to hire akira toriyama for their next rpg and stop trying to release huge cinematic events, just fucking make a good game.

your opinion doesn't matter after you talk about how Chrono Trigger is overrated.

[Lazortag]

Originally Posted by Autotune [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

your opinion doesn't matter after you talk about how Chrono Trigger is overrated.

How is chrono trigger not overrated?

None of the characters are very well developed or even engaging, there's little subtlety in the game and all of the side quests and encounters are completely spelled out for you with no room left for the player to figure things out on their own. In other RPG's in its era you actually had to think for more than 2 seconds to get by some of the more difficult parts in the game, whereas Chrono Trigger was generally way too easy. I also didn't feel the time travel element of the game was handled very well (I remember some chests where if you opened them in the past, you could still open them in the future for example... I know it's small but it's still kind of lame and makes the game less immersive).

I did really like that one world with the really advanced civilization that I think was around ~15000 BCE or something. That's probably one of my favorite parts of any RPG. The rest of the game seemed a lot less inspired though.

[Autotune]

Originally Posted by Lazortag [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

How is chrono trigger not overrated?

None of the characters are very well developed or even engaging, there's little subtlety in the game and all of the side quests and encounters are completely spelled out for you with no room left for the player to figure things out on their own. In other RPG's in its era you actually had to think for more than 2 seconds to get by some of the more difficult parts in the game, whereas Chrono Trigger was generally way too easy. I also didn't feel the time travel element of the game was handled very well (I remember some chests where if you opened them in the past, you could still open them in the future for example... I know it's small but it's still kind of lame and makes the game less immersive).

I did really like that one world with the really advanced civilization that I think was around ~15000 BCE or something. That's probably one of my favorite parts of any RPG. The rest of the game seemed a lot less inspired though.

I've never thought of Chrono Trigger being rated so high in the first place. From everything I've ever seen/heard about the game, it's just a 'great game'. Anything less and it would be just a "meh, game" which hardly comes to mind when I think of Chrono Trigger.

Could be slightly overrated, but that could describe any game.

[Feachie]

Originally Posted by Autotune [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

your opinion doesn't matter after you talk about how Chrono Trigger is overrated.

i can talk about how overrated something is but still enjoy it for what it is.

somewhat related

[karsten]

Originally Posted by Autotune [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

your opinion doesn't matter after you talk about how Chrono Trigger is overrated.

[karsten]

also the battle system in all of the secret of mana games was super gay, and I found that whole star ocean secret of mana etc line to be terribly boring

[Glitch]

Originally Posted by karsten [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

also the battle system in all of the secret of mana games was super gay, and I found that whole star ocean secret of mana etc line to be terribly boring

Karsten, you are hereby banished from Potos Village.

[Xadion]

Originally Posted by karsten [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

also the battle system in all of the secret of mana games was super gay, and I found that whole star ocean secret of mana etc line to be terribly boring

I admit.. I got Star Ocean Till the End of Time for PS2 and was uber excited- loaded it up told the game to STFU and move on I want some story! I got into a battle with 3 robots and died over and over and over...never has it touched my console again...

sooo star ocean dirives from the Secret of Mana/Evermore etc line? I could deal with the 2 SNES ones but not for very long I never made it to the end of those two.

[Mardur]

Originally Posted by karsten [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

also the battle system in all of the secret of mana games was super gay

your opinion doesn't matter after you talk about how the battle system of secret of mana sucks.