Stormfeather rules need to change

[grims]

The assumption is wrong though, there is not always someone there participating in the camp.

I leave after every camp most often times its just strait up open.

There is one high end raid item I bought that was less than a mill o.o of that I have other plat camps that I do.

I will see about taking the time to post the countless number of videos and screenshots I took in the past with no one in the camp and logging after after expecting some dudes to come lie and engage in defamation and slander. Its just going to take a lot of time. Good ole quote a lie gets half way around the world before the truth gets its pants on

Text logs were easier to post quickly but will post those as well later just will take a lot of time to upload them.


Take camp:
[Mon Jun 15 04:29:02 2026] Auragrimhc -> X: AFK Message: Feel free to take #1 in camp, just here for a tod ^ ^. Discord "grim03743" if looking for a camp service

[Sun Jun 14 16:22:43 2026] Auragrimhc -> X: AFK Message: Feel free to take #1 in camp, just here for a tod ^ ^. Discord "grim03743" if looking for a camp service

For redundancy leaving it to feel free to take #1 and only posting 1 per day, there are often 6+ messages in one day for someone to take the camp as I make trades / help port / give people free items / help people know lodi windows.


Again these were times where I know the camp was open prior its 15 hours between spawns, only reason I dont put names in here is because there are gents intentionally lying / dont want them annoying anyone they can that they see interacted.

[Sat Jun 13 22:08:21 2026] Auragrimhc -> X : AFK Message: Feel free to take #1 in camp

[Sat Jun 06 22:46:20 2026] Auragrimhc -> X : AFK Message: Feel free to take #1

[Sun May 10 03:11:00 2026] Auragrimhc -> X : AFK Message: Feel free to take #1

[Tue Apr 28 13:18:08 2026] Auragrimhc -> X : AFK Message: Feel free to take #1

[Mon Apr 13 21:27:57 2026] Auragrimhc -> X : AFK Message: Feel free to take #1

[Tue Apr 07 11:32:27 2026] Auragrimhc -> X : AFK Message: Feel free to take #1

[Sun Apr 05 21:09:02 2026] Auragrimhc -> X : AFK Message: Feel free to take #1

[Sat Apr 04 22:53:20 2026] Auragrimhc -> X: AFK Message: Feel free to take #1

[Tue Mar 31 01:29:58 2026] Auragrimhc -> X: AFK Message: Feel free to take #1

[Fri Mar 13 09:56:05 2026] Auragrimhc -> X: AFK Message: Feel free to take #1

[Sun Mar 08 20:38:02 2026] Auragrimhc -> X: AFK Message: Feel free to take #1

[Sat Mar 07 21:06:02 2026] Auragrimhc -> X: AFK Message: feel free to take #1

[Mon Mar 02 20:12:30 2026] Ambientwarmth -> X: AFK Message: Feel free to take #1

[Fri Feb 13 10:48:12 2026] Ambientwarmth -> X: AFK Message: Hey ^ ^, just here for time of death good luck / feel free to claim #1

[Fri Feb 13 10:48:56 2026] X -> Ambientwarmth: Ahh Okay ..... I am gonna take #1 on list spot & thank you

If there were any made up anything on the logs there would be someone making a claim and posting a log, I record the vast majority of my camps start to finish so no one can be manipulative after.


Something really important here as well. TOD is extremely important in this camp, the camp is at its absolute worse when you dont know it, your not doing yourself or anyone else any favors not asking and getting pissy about it after. 75 hours x 60 mins is 4500 minutes, if you check it once every 5 minutes thats a one in 900 chance the camp will randomly spawn. If you know windows and it goes the full duration its 20 hours x 60 mins divided by 5
its 240.

You are almost 4x more likely to get a spawn if asking for a TOD than showing up randomly and getting upset. Its much better when you know the time / who was there for last spawn.

So its important to note the person starting this thread never asked me once before throwing out baseless shameful accusations in order to defame and slander without a shred of substantiation or proof

I aim to make this camp easier for self campers and want everyone who comes through to feel treated fairly that I interact with which is the vast majority of self campers outside of the ones that show up randomly ask for no info and get upset a camp that can spawn once every 75 hours is not spawning while they watch the clock.

There is a guildie of his that got the camp before I knew about this thread (with no one in camp2 hours before window) that I tod'd (they asked on discord because I was not there). They asked for it they got it and now they dont have to spend 4x as much time watching their PC/ losing sleep because they have it. Not knowing who got TOD is 10x worse for everyone involved.

[Zuranthium]

Originally Posted by DeathsSilkyMist [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Rotations are hard to enforce, as the staff has to do it.

Classic rotations don't need any extra staff involvement with the /list mechanic. The difference is that /list is supposed to only give you rights to kill an NPC 1 time when it's your turn.

[BradZax]

why is there a scout roll, but not a roll for every other mob as well?

[DeathsSilkyMist]

Originally Posted by Zuranthium [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Classic rotations don't need any extra staff involvement

I am discussing how P99 actually works, not your ideas of what classic Everquest are. Please stop saying "but classic!". It's off-topic.

On P99, rotations are enforced by the staff, as is /List. That is why the only official rotation on P99 is Sky.

[tiger32kw]

Originally Posted by grims [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I aim to make this camp easier for self campers and want everyone who comes through to feel treated fairly that I interact with which is the vast majority of self campers outside of the ones that show up randomly ask for no info and get upset a camp that can spawn once every 75 hours is not spawning while they watch the clock.

You don't though. You make the camp worse for everyone and tell yourself you make it better while profiting off of your endeavor. It's gross.

Nobody is saying you are breaking the rules, we are saying we need to change the rules because you used them to ruin this camp for everyone.

Still waiting on you to say how many Stormfeathers you have killed overall on your logs across all chars.

[Zuranthium]

Originally Posted by DeathsSilkyMist [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Please stop saying "but classic!". It's off-topic.

No it isn't. That's literally THE topic of p99. You're the one who is constantly off-topic.

Originally Posted by DeathsSilkyMist [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I am discussing how P99 actually works.

You're not discussing anything of value. You're wasting space, like usual. Everyone already knows what the rules are currently. The current rules are bad, and should be changed.

Writing inane shit like "none of these solutions will make everybody happy" is completely unproductive. Nothing in the world would ever improve for the better if people had that mentality. Good rules are supposed to create the most amount of benefit. It's generally always a question of weighing the pros and cons, and finding the best solution. Not letting a stagnant, harmful status quo remain.

[OriginalContentGuy]

Does anyone know any of these people involved in-game or are they all just bot sockpuppets?

Originally Posted by Grims

I aim to make this camp easier for self campers and want everyone who comes through to feel treated fairly that I interact with which is the vast majority of self campers outside of the ones that show up randomly ask for no info and get upset a camp that can spawn once every 75 hours is not spawning while they watch the clock.

I don't know anything about Green but on Blue I could almost buy the idea that no one bothers to PM the camp holder despite logging in almost like they don't know how to use chat.

[DeathsSilkyMist]

Originally Posted by Zuranthium [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

No it isn't. That's literally THE topic of p99. You're the one who is constantly off-topic.

Incorrect. There is a reason why the forums have different sections. If someone asks "how do quakes work on P99"? In the Green Server Chat section, it is not appropriate to say "P99 quakes did not exist on classic!". You answer their question regarding how quakes work on P99 like a normal person.

People ask questions about P99 on the P99 forums, so they can get answers on how P99 currently works. This is basic logic 101.

Stick to the appropriate forum sections and threads for discussing what is and is not classic.

Originally Posted by Zuranthium [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

You're not discussing anything of value. You're wasting space, like usual. Everyone already knows what the rules are currently. The current rules are bad, and should be changed.

Writing inane shit like "none of these solutions will make everybody happy" is completely unproductive. Nothing in the world would ever improve for the better if people had that mentality. Good rules are supposed to create the most amount of benefit. It's generally always a question of weighing the pros and cons, and finding the best solution. Not letting a stagnant, harmful status quo remain.

You haven't come up with any reasonable solutions. I am looking at the reality of how P99 works. Your fantasies about P99 are irrelevant.

[BradZax]

Why not scout roll?

Why is scout a roll.

[Defo]

Scout Rolls < Cinnamon Rolls