Discussion: +/- 8 Levels, Dynamic

[Rushmore]

all zones with the best gear should be ffa period..... Upper Guk would have +/- pvp range.

I don't mind a level range but in certain zones like where manastone and guise drop there should be FFA. People can just make mages and camp gear without harassment.

[Bardalicious]

Originally Posted by Rushmore [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

all zones with the best gear should be ffa period..... Upper Guk would have +/- pvp range.

I don't mind a level range but in certain zones like where manastone and guise drop there should be FFA. People can just make mages and camp gear without harassment.

Or since you're level 50 and that 30-some is trying to camp a manastone you just fucking KS him because it's a PVP server?

[Rushmore]

Originally Posted by Bardalicious [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Or since you're level 50 and that 30-some is trying to camp a manastone you just fucking KS him because it's a PVP server?

the last guy I would think would be against me on this

[Bardalicious]

Originally Posted by Rushmore [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

the last guy I would think would be against me on this

You are proposing implementing FFA xp in one of very few zones that people will have to level up in simply because of pre-nerf guise and manastone. If you're level 50 and have level 50 friends, why does it matter if lowbies are trying to camp the shit?

You move in and take the camp and laugh at them while they can't do anything to retaliate.

[Haul]

Originally Posted by Bardalicious [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Or since you're level 50 and that 30-some is trying to camp a manastone you just fucking KS him because it's a PVP server?

Real talk.

[Buhbuh]

Aside from the fact that teams will X-team from day one no matter how you choose to hard code the server, yes, it will probably be hard to balance them.

I think there's a bigger issue at hand regarding the idea of making teams: population. From a statistical standpoint, with 400 people playing at any given time, roughly 100 of those will be hard coded as people I can't kill? That sounds not very good, to put it lightly. What's more is that-- who will I be in a guild with? Will I necessarily stick to my team? Probably not. I will probably X-team. That makes even less people dead by my PvP loving hands.

If R99 is even half the population of P99, the teams idea just doesn't pan out. I'm sure developers could make it WoW- like, where teams can't group with others, etc. etc. But I'm not big on that.

Remember with TZ, VZ, SZ, and RZ we all saw 1000+ playing there in the beginning.

Let's not pretend that is a luxury here. FFA seems like the most logical option.

[Humerox]

Originally Posted by Buhbuh [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

...I think there's a bigger issue at hand regarding the idea of making teams: population...

That's going to be the problem...otherwise I'd tend to agree with you. No matter what any emu PvP server does - and I daresay that will include Red99 - population is going to be a problem. Sure, some may start up for the novelty, but keeping them in and actually increasing population will take some serious thought and creativity.

A FFA environment doesn't stimulate growth, imo (even tho I personally prefer a hardcore FFA experience)...and I also think it wouldn't attract the population lost from P99 over the last couple of years.

I don't think there are enough experienced red players to support any kind of sustained growth. The blues have to be drawn in, and that's going to require a secure PvE experience (or one that FEELS secure to some extent).

I'd forgotten about the race-based concept; I didn't play any PvP server much except SZ, but race would probably be the way to go.

I applaud Rogean and team for actually going with this...but there have to be more prizes in the box. [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

[Buhbuh]

Originally Posted by Humerox [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

That's going to be the problem...otherwise I'd tend to agree with you. No matter what any emu PvP server does - and I daresay that will include Red99 - population is going to be a problem. Sure, some may start up for the novelty, but keeping them in and actually increasing population will take some serious thought and creativity.

A FFA environment doesn't stimulate growth, imo (even tho I personally prefer a hardcore FFA experience)...and I also think it wouldn't attract the population lost from P99 over the last couple of years.

I don't think there are enough experienced red players to support any kind of sustained growth. The blues have to be drawn in, and that's going to require a secure PvE experience (or one that FEELS secure to some extent).

I'd forgotten about the race-based concept; I didn't play any PvP server much except SZ, but race would probably be the way to go.

I applaud Rogean and team for actually going with this...but there have to be more prizes in the box. [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

To an extent. I agree that there was some security in teams/ race based (some players I would have preferred not to mess with), but it wouldn't destroy my good time if I had to get down with them. The flip side is that there were some people I really wish I could have attacked on my team back on live. For population growth and sustainability, though?

I think the mere fact that the P99 crew is doing this is enough to keep people playing. This candid discussion is more than we got on those makeshift classic boxes. They fix things and want feedback. Maybe most of it is awful, barely readable feedback, but at least they want to give people somewhat of a voice.

You have a point in giving security with teams, but I honestly think it's a stretch to call it game-breaking for the bluebies coming here.

What stopped them from coming to other PvP servers were things like AC, poisons, Strength, Disarm, skillups, and the majority of quests not working, clearly exaggerated imbalances (Warriors crit for 1500? Not crip, crit...in classic), backstab hitting for less than flying kick with top end piercers, 'Whirl Til You Hurl' acting as a T-staff stun, in game help basically absent, etc.

Mechanics aren't really a problem here.

[Rushmore]

Originally Posted by Humerox [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

That's going to be the problem...otherwise I'd tend to agree with you. No matter what any emu PvP server does - and I daresay that will include Red99 - population is going to be a problem. Sure, some may start up for the novelty, but keeping them in and actually increasing population will take some serious thought and creativity.

A FFA environment doesn't stimulate growth, imo (even tho I personally prefer a hardcore FFA experience)...and I also think it wouldn't attract the population lost from P99 over the last couple of years.

I don't think there are enough experienced red players to support any kind of sustained growth. The blues have to be drawn in, and that's going to require a secure PvE experience (or one that FEELS secure to some extent).

I'd forgotten about the race-based concept; I didn't play any PvP server much except SZ, but race would probably be the way to go.

I applaud Rogean and team for actually going with this...but there have to be more prizes in the box. [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I have to respectfully disagree with you here. In an age where there are no true challenging mmo games anymore this is our only home. We only need a well coded sustainable server to call home. And once that happens we will all rapture to it. And all that is heavenly glory will be.

the low population or the inconsistency has been ONLY from the inconsistency. We've always been here in waiting.