Warriors are useless in 90% of the games content

[Snaggles]

Originally Posted by Ripqozko [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Wars do, rangers don’t

Using Lucy's damage bonus table and the napkin-math calculation, ratio wise the Mel and the Twisted are very close.

Twisted Steel Bastard Sword 3.20
Melijeldin Bane of the Giants 3.210
Vulaxe 3.238

The whole premise is very stupid though. The only time I could see even putting forth the tryhard effort (ie it actually working but being a PITA) is if the Tantor's Tusk had a better ratio. Say like 65/60 or something. Swapping weapon sets every 3 seconds haste capped would still be a chore without programmable hardware which is not allowed by my understanding of the P99 rule set.

In general, all melees should...
Use the best weapons possible
Get the best buffs possible
Melee as much as you can without dying
Use some dirty tricks if you got them, swap outs like primals, cast nukes, BFG etc.

Don't spend time tinfoil hat thinking outside the box. You can only do what you can do. Any time a warrior or ranger beats a rogue should be a celebration because in general if its apples vs apples that won't happen often.