Rolling a SK or warrior

[DeathsSilkyMist]

It depends on if the third person sticks with Enchanter, or goes Shaman. If the third person goes Shaman, SK will be better because a Cleric/Warrior/Shaman trio is very limited on pulling. You would have to rely on the Cleric to lull, which is going to significantly hurt their ability to regenerate mana. You could also root CC with the Shaman, but that can be dangerous and very mana heavy, especially before Torpor.

If the third person goes Enchanter, I agree Warrior may be the better option in this scenario. The Enchanter can do the pulling, and if this group sticks together and hits 60, they could do some specific money camps that would benefit more from a Warrior's ability to disc. But it does depend on what camps they are aiming for. Cleric/Shadowknight/Enchanter would be better for Fungi Tunic camp, for example.

OP says he doesn't raid, so he has more flexibility on tank choice. However, I do agree with Keebz that rolling Warrior is a safer bet from a future proofing perspective. People change over time, and you may regret rolling an SK if you suddenly get the urge to go ham on raiding. Sadly SKs are the worst raiding class in the game, so you should be very aware of that, especially since most people take a long time to level a character to 60.