Enchanter charm isn't classic, we all know this

[Dolalin]

There were a lot of little charm bugs and things that made charming less attractive on Live than it is now.

1) Nobody had GCD refresh items
2) Tashan line was resistable until May 1999
3) CHA *might* be giving too much of a charm duration bonus here
4) Charmed pets would randomly not obey /pet commands
5) Charmed pets would randomly attack groupmates
6) Mobs 35+ *probably* had higher MR across the board
7) Pets in groups should steal a full share of xp if they outdamage the entire group

That's off the top of my head. It's not just any one thing.