A Shady Goblin (Ring Roll) in Warsilk Woods

[loramin]

Originally Posted by Senescant [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

We've seen 2-3 people on the forums push things down. I'll try ingame tonight when we have a better grasp of how more people feels about it.

You tried pushing the clickfest idea in-game (hard), and it still failed. You are not Shady Goblin Jesus. You are not the person responsible for trying to make everything Shady Goblin-related perfect.

We established a good, fair, and simple system. You were a big part of it. Congrats.

Now sit back on your laurels and wait for Shady like everyone else. Stop trying to think you can magically convince twenty rotating people to all agree to to whatever latest harebrained scheme you've come up with that you haven't even taken the time to work the flaws out of.

It's like you've completely ignored/forgotten everything that ever happened before. Scout didn't just happen. People spent countless forum posts arguing over how the roll should work. The very idea of it, and exactly how it should work, was "battle-tested" there. Then it was further tested in months of in-game arguments. It was only after all that that everyone finally agreed to the roll.

The only reason Shady went so much smoother was because we had the example of Scout, and because the roll was all but identical to the Scout roll (just with added variance). When you keep trying to push other schemes you're not doing any of that, yet you keep pushing and failing.