charm: some actual evidence rather than QQ

[Blingx]

Originally Posted by guineapig [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Before any expansions were released, enchanters were soloing the ghoul lord and fire giants area with charmed pets.

Originally Posted by ziah

Join Date: Jul 2002
Posts: 6
-1 Internets
Before any expansions were released, enchanters were soloing the ghoul lord and fire giants area with charmed pets.

Jul 2002

Release date - Planes of Power - 2002
Outdated info is outdated.

Let me try putting it this way. Quoting someone in 2002 whom is remembering something that happened in 2001 is no different than quoting someone yesterday whom remembered something in 2001.

The goal is to quote someone in 2001 saying something about 2001. (Present tense)

That exact post from FOH has been thrown around these threads like candy and all pro-charmers rally behind it like a gospel, when in fact, its credibility is near zero; just like his post count. It has no sources(ss/data/logs) only 1 post saying "Hey this is how I remember it."
Deja vu~

[Blingx]

Lets assume charm is horribly left of center.

Argument:
Charm is broke.

Reason:
Cannot charm mob a->n for desired length of time.

Proof:
Post x says we can charm solo FGs for desired length of time, sometimes.


When posting quotes about being able to solo FGs, it might make sense to actually go and try to solo FGs before claiming charm is broke.
Where are these log attempts?

[yaeger]

I was going to make fun of all you whiners who complain about charm not being as effective now. But I'm not going to do that.

We definitely need charm fixed so enchanters can solo all non-raid content because that's exactly what this game needs. More solo classes to be exploited so this can become more and more non-classic in terms of game-play.

Posts that focus on why Enchanters should remain stupid OP while classes like Rangers, acknowledged underdogs in classic, get minimal support and make me question whether or not any of you are concerned about the bigger picture of the server.

You guys only seem to do research and defend to the death only the things that will benefit you. I hate you for trying.

Whoops, looked like I started in on the whiners, sorry guys.