Discussion about what constitutes a camp and how to hold a camp

[fastboy21]

Originally Posted by Teppler [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Can no one truly claim north in howling stones if they are soloing? Can a group come in and take over?

You're trying to extrapolate an answer to a specific question, to which you want a certain answer, by asking questions that aren't relevant.

Yes, someone solo'ing can probably claim the named in HS north. No, a group probably can't come in and take over. Howling Stones north isn't Sebilis crypt (no matter how much you want it to be).

The rules don't exist so that folks can get away with doing things that are against the spirit of the rules.

This is why the rules are left general and GMs are given the latitude to examine situations on a case by case basis, use precedent, and apply the general principles of the rules.