@Sirken "a fair and legitimate chance at that target"

[Phantasm]

They gave it their best shot, ultimately not resulting in a kill. If another guild wants to offer a guild that failed already a shot at success who are you to say otherwise ? Thats how you learn man, not by having neckbeards breathing down your neck while they count out your stopwatch. THey were offered an opportunity to kill a mob that they failed on. The fact they got no loot is beside the point. THey gained experience and vital time on target, perhaps enabling them success in the future.