Consider Project 2002

[Ella`Ella]

Originally Posted by Haynar [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Takp is a great server. P2002 might be too. P2002 just has a more hands-off approach by GMs which will be more appealing to some. More paricularly when it comes to managing raid rotations, etc..

H

Haynar, do you favor or oppose strong GM intervention in the raid scene?

[Haynar]

Originally Posted by Ella`Ella [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Haynar, do you favor or oppose strong GM intervention in the raid scene?

I favor strong GM intervention when those that are raiding cannot get along. Translation, when it creates more work for the GMs from all the drama, and the raid scene is nothing but a cesspool of scum and villany, and GM intervention actually makes it less work then, yes to GM intervention.

If you can have raiding guilds work it out and get along? Then let them manage it.

I have never seen it work out on its own, for competetive raiding on eqemu.

Example: p99.

Takp: the users voted to manage themselves, but then they did nothing to actually manage it. Lots of drama. GMs intervened.

P2002: no competetive raid scene. Basically one guild raiding last I heard.

EQEmu raiders don't get along, in a real competitive environment.

[BossThunderace]

Originally Posted by Haynar [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I favor strong GM intervention when those that are raiding cannot get along. Translation, when it creates more work for the GMs from all the drama, and the raid scene is nothing but a cesspool of scum and villany, and GM intervention actually makes it less work then, yes to GM intervention.

If you can have raiding guilds work it out and get along? Then let them manage it.

I have never seen it work out on its own, for competetive raiding on eqemu.

Example: p99.

Takp: the users voted to manage themselves, but then they did nothing to actually manage it. Lots of drama. GMs intervened.

P2002: no competetive raid scene. Basically one guild raiding last I heard.

EQEmu raiders don't get along, in a real competitive environment.

Any recollection of AK live?

Non-GM intervention, 2 or 3 guilds at the top of progression, respectfully rotated raid mobs.

...

takp = GM intervention raid scene

p2002 = Non-GM intervention raid scene

pick your posion

[Alarti0001]

Originally Posted by Haynar [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I favor strong GM intervention when those that are raiding cannot get along. Translation, when it creates more work for the GMs from all the drama, and the raid scene is nothing but a cesspool of scum and villany, and GM intervention actually makes it less work then, yes to GM intervention.

If you can have raiding guilds work it out and get along? Then let them manage it.

I have never seen it work out on its own, for competetive raiding on eqemu.

Example: p99.

Takp: the users voted to manage themselves, but then they did nothing to actually manage it. Lots of drama. GMs intervened.

P2002: no competetive raid scene. Basically one guild raiding last I heard.

EQEmu raiders don't get along, in a real competitive environment.

Not sure how P99 is an example. The raid guilds never had the freedom to manage themselves.

[KagatobLuvsAnimu]

Originally Posted by Alarti0001 [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Not sure how P99 is an example. The raid guilds never had the freedom to manage themselves.

You're still as full of shit as ever I see.

[Champion_Standing]

Originally Posted by Alarti0001 [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Not sure how P99 is an example. The raid guilds never had the freedom to manage themselves.

Sure they were, just couldn't handle it. Pretty sure the first raid ever on p99 needed gm babysitting. Secrets tell us some stories plz?