Trackers in Agro Range of Raid Targets. Severilous last night, needs community input

[Artaenc]

Originally Posted by -Catherin- [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

ah forget it, deleted this post. Since none of the other guilds are saying anything this isn't going to go anywhere past you and me bickering back and forth. I'll be happy to know that you guys get it and don't try to do this again.

I was on vacation and just saw this. I expect this kind of treatment when we do the exact same thing. Otherwise this is a crystal clear violation of the rules. I would say two weeks raiding suspension should fix this issue and if they try to rule lawyer it some more then take the time to look at the logs to get the mage tracker's position and add one more week per hour he/she was there.

This type of negligence of the rules is making it very difficult to enjoy playing on this server especially when guilds get away with it.

[Drakakade]

If Taken petitioned TMO for violating a clearly stated raid policy, then the responsibility for adjudicating the decision rests with the GMs who have more tools at their disposal to judge the validity of the petition than a grab bag of C and R guilds with various levels of asymmetric information.

Presumably, said GMs will also decide on whether enough evidence has been presented or the defense is adequate, and I would think any punishment would also be tailored to whether a guild had sufficient raid experience to know better or not. For example, a hapless new guild to the server might inadvertently break the rules and be granted leniency, as opposed to a more experienced guild with a robust working knowledge of the existing rules and one working to foster a better raiding environment.

Again, thank-you, Staff and Devs for P99.