My proposal for Raiding guilds and GMs of P1999

[Phallax]

Originally Posted by Alawen Everywhere [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I think everyone knows by now that I'm a pretty straight shooter, so here's exactly what I think.

I think we have been hearing about the "new sheriff" in town for several weeks. We've heard a lot of trash talk from a guild that recruited a huge zerg of anyone level 46 or over that has never killed more than 50% of bosses in a given cycle, despite turning the raid scene into the big sit. We've seen and taken screen shots of a DA officer training our raids. We've had DA leadership actively lie to a GM in order to receive an additional attempt.

If this proposal had come two or three weeks ago, there would still be many issues with it. I'm not an officer and I don't speak for my guild, but I don't expect many of us to welcome this proposal at all now.

From my perspective, I don't see a solid core to DA. I see a huge number of officers (10? 12? how many officers do you guys have?) trying to hold together a guild full of recent 50s with the highest turnover rate I've ever seen in an MMO guild. This proposal looks completely disingenuous to me. I think there is a rising dissent within DA from members who want to camp items from non-raid targets that they are missing, build some wealth on the server, develop alts and just have a good time. I think this negotiation comes from a position of increasing weakness.

Before DA, IB was like a conventional raid guild. We'd have our small tracking team (like me!) watching for raid targets while everyone did their thing, whether online or offline. When something popped, we'd let each other know, assemble and mobilize. We were good at it and many guilds discovered that they weren't as fast as we are. DA's leadership decided to eliminate mobilization from the equation with camping. Now we have a DA officer proposing rotation because they're tired of camping.

Here's the bottom line: from where I sit, it seems like DA thought a couple weeks of camping would destroy IB. Instead, it's destroying DA. It looks like a couple more weeks of camping 24/7 will return the server to raid strategies involving tracking and mobilization.

Just like classic EQ.

^ this. DA's intention WAS to "try" and destroy IB. Believe me I saw the guild text and "lawl" statements and how they think theyre playing chess, its humorous at best. DA is weakening, they were getting weak the first week of it but kept trying to shrug it off by claiming how IB was getting weak.

A new system is needed but I think it needs to be thoroughly ironed out in a good discussion thread such as this over weeks of time, not 1 night sitting in mumble/TS shootin random shit all night.

It needs input from the enitre server, not just a handful of officers from different guilds.

Nizzarr out of the very few DA I still have respect for, you are 1 and I think this proposal is a good base to start the new rules, that are needed, off of.