Coldain Prayer Shawl vs Neriad for Enc queztion

[oldschoolguy]

so level 54, i can go for either since im at 158 tailoring and can get 6 pretty fast (7 is last one). is CPS that helpful on chanter with our self buffed mana regen? or waste if time and better get Neriad one?

Charisma not an issue i already maxed out with old self buff.