Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it. (Wall of Text)

[Molitoth]

So why not fix it in a way that promotes competition and skill?

The only way to fix this in EQ is to add Instances and see what guild is the most skilled to do with the least amount of people.

At least, thats the solution SOE came up with.

In P99 everyone knows the strats for every encounter, there will never be skill involved again. Sorry.