It's official: Riot is done.

[Croco]

Originally Posted by Samoht [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I don't see where that removes the ruling regarding lull being illegal in foot race FTEs. The post does include specifics on what was removed, and lull pulling was not a part of it.

If you can link me one instance of Sirken or any other server GM saying anything about lull pulling being against the rules in a different thread besides the aforementioned thread "ToV & King Tormax / Statue Specific Rules" then I will concede your point.

I contend that since there is no mention of lull being against the rules in the P99 blue server raiding rules or any addendum except the single sentence in question, which you keep taking out of the context of the thread it was posted in, then it's clearly not against the rules. Not then, and not currently.

You can't just imply something is true with zero proof. I can't say that the thread titled "ToV & King Tormax / Statue Specific Rules" is about Veeshan's Peak because there's no proof of that. That entire thread up until Galach's edit over 3 years later has nothing to do with Dain or icewell. Everything in this thread that Sirken posted is with regard to the title "ToV & King Tormax / Statue Specific Rules". You can tell that because those rules you're trying to say exist for everything aren't listed in the general p99 blue server raiding rules.

I'm sorry for your sake that Sirken made rules in his head and never documented them. Guess what? Those aren't rules. If they aren't documented they don't apply and Sirken isn't the GM anymore. I'm not sure if you've noticed but the current staff has been taking a hatchet to almost all Sirken era rules for reasons.

It absolutely is Galach's job to post Sirken's rules or his own rules if he wants those rules to apply to p99 raiding. I'm not asking you to have insight into anything I'm just asking you to examine what is and what isn't. What is: lull is mentioned once, in a thread specifically talking about ToV, KT & Statue. What isn't: Lull, isn't mentioned literally anywhere else.

You are the one imposing your own "insight" into the situation by assuming something that isn't true. So show me the evidence. Show me a link to a rule that existed during the time we lull pulled dain that expressly states it was against the rules.