Solo shm vs nec (budget edition)

[Tann]

Who would overall be a better soloer and money maker? Budget style, no epics, no expensive spells, no clickies. I know shamans are solo kings with Torpor but what if that ain't even close to feasible.

Figuring a sub 10k budget does the necro win? They could afford almost their whole toolkit with that budget.

Shamans get hosed, Malo is at least 10k, Pox and Bane are twice that easily, and obviously Torpor still more than all those combined. Are they still stronk without that stuff?