Manastone /List yet another idea

[Erati]

Originally Posted by Tilien [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I would agree this is possible but it would require a constant stream of non ask guildies to actually monopolize, and person 1 and 5 could still work together to kill it.

Assuming the guild will try to blockade the camp anyway would you rather have a system where the guild requires larger coordination (because if more nonguildies show up there could become a block of unguilded at the front) and forces the guild to actually clear the camp?

Or have one where the guild can blockade indefinitely or never clear camp?

Imagine a guild has positions 1-4 and refuse to assist the kill because 5 is unguilded. Once the unguilded is gone killing resumes.

Lots of ways to abuse both systems, I think one is marginally better than the other.

I am merely giving examples of where a system that removes people from the list due to not engaging PH can be abused and exploited for gain.

Right now does it suck when people dont help clear the mobs and the #One cant solo it - yes - but that usually comes down to whether people are assholes or not and eventually itll get worked out with petition or simple conversation.

If you tempt people by hardcoding a way that boots people off lists outside of AFK checks, people WILL abuse it to get people they dont like booted.