Manastone /List yet another idea

[Tilien]

Originally Posted by Erati [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

#1 on List is a Random but Nice person unable to solo the mob
#2-4 is all from the same guild and have orders to not help non guildies at list camps so more people join their guild

If you implement a system that allows a guild to monopolize list by ordering “no help” to anyone not tagged which in turn resets the list, you just made it easier to monopolize list camps w a zerg guild.

I would agree this is possible but it would require a constant stream of non ask guildies to actually monopolize, and person 1 and 5 could still work together to kill it.

Assuming the guild will try to blockade the camp anyway would you rather have a system where the guild requires larger coordination (because if more nonguildies show up there could become a block of unguilded at the front) and forces the guild to actually clear the camp?

Or have one where the guild can blockade indefinitely or never clear camp?

Imagine a guild has positions 1-4 and refuse to assist the kill because 5 is unguilded. Once the unguilded is gone killing resumes.

Lots of ways to abuse both systems, I think one is marginally better than the other.